Metcalfe was twice elected to the
Alaska House of Representatives as a Republican. He formed the
Republican Moderate Party of Alaska in 1986, to oppose the
religious right who he felt had invaded and taken over the Republican Party, and ran for the Alaska House again attempting to beat the incumbent Republican he had lost his former seat to in 1982. Shortly after Metcalfe formed the RMP, the leaders of the Republican Party sued him for forming a group using the term "Republican" without their permission. Metcalfe won in Superior Court and the Republican Party did not appeal. The Superior Court had declared Metcalfe to be a "Public Litigant," "litigating in the public interest in defense of free speech for all." Consequently, under Alaska's court rules, the new leaders of the Republican Party were ordered to pay all Metcalfe's attorney fees. His political runs for the state House and the governor's office were unsuccessful but he received over 6% of the vote in the
1998 gubernatorial election, when the Republican vote had been split between three unsuccessful Republican candidates. In 2006, Metcalfe ran as a Democrat for the sole U.S. House seat from Alaska, coming in second to
Diane E. Benson by receiving 34% of the vote in the Democratic primary. In 2008 the Republican Moderate Party lost its party status and remained as a political group, while the Citizens For Ethical Government Inc., a non profit political
watchdog group, was created. Metcalfe again declared he was running as a Democrat, this time for the US Senate seat held by
Ted Stevens, but he lost in the 2008 Democratic primary. In 2016, Metcalfe lost his bid to become regional Co-Chair of the Anchorage branch of the Alaska Democratic Party to Joshua Spring by a two to one margin. In the August 16, 2016 primary, Metcalfe won the Democratic nomination to oppose Republican U.S. Senator
Lisa Murkowski. On November 8, 2016 he placed fourth in the general election behind Murkowski (44%),
Libertarian Joe Miller (30%), and
Independent Margaret Stock (14%). Metcalfe received 11% of the vote. In 2020, Metcalfe sought the Republican nomination for
district M in the
Alaska Senate. He received approximately 24% of the vote, placing second behind incumbent
Josh Revak. ==See also ==