Janet Maslin of
The New York Times praised the film as an "often very funny assault on manners, moviemaking, an allegedly typical American family and everything its members hold dear ... Its manner is deadpan and sly, so sly that some viewers may not find it comic at all. But for anyone well-disposed toward Mr. Brooks, who is never without his absolute insincerity and irrational good cheer,
Real Life is full of delightful nonsense, a very funny account of one man's crusade to capture all the truth and wisdom that money can buy."
Variety said: "Expanding on the deadpan satiric tone of the short parodies and pseudo-documentaries he's filmed in the past for NBC's
Saturday Night Live into his first feature, Albert Brooks has come up with a mostly very funny (though uneven) take-off on social-minded docu filmmaking that stands to draw boxoffice support from the young adult, primarily college crowd that's made the late-night tv show the success it is."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film three-and-a-half stars out of four, and wrote: "Admittedly, documentary filmmaking doesn't sound like the greatest subject to be satirized, but
Real Life is full of undeniable laughs."
Charles Champlin of the
Los Angeles Times called Grodin "wonderful to watch" and thought that the film "generates some spectacular moments," but "the movie, like the experiment, runs out of steam well before it is finished and, like many a promising routine, is stuck for a sock ending." Gary Arnold of
The Washington Post stated: "Albert Brooks may be the
Woody Allen of the 1980s. His extraordinary first feature,
Real Life, demonstrates a potential genius for movie comedy and is animated by a peculiarly fertile and subtle imagination."
David Ansen of
Newsweek wrote that the film "doesn't quite come off, for all its funny ideas. It feels like a 30-minute gag stretched to fill a feature film, and the repetitiousness of the situation gets wearisome. It's a one-note movie, and Brooks's performance doesn't help: he's like an aggressive emcee who doesn't know when to shut up and turn the show over to his guests. That may be the point, but it's also the problem."
Roger Ebert gave the film one star out of four and wrote that it "gets most of its laughs in the first 10 minutes, slides into a long middle stretch of repetitive situations and ends on a note of embarrassing hysteria. An idea is not enough for a movie. Characters have to be developed, comic situations have to be set up before they can pay off and the story should have a conclusion instead of a dead stop.
Real Life fails in all of those areas — fails so miserably that it lets its audiences down."
Real Life holds a rating of 84% on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 25 reviews, with an average score of 6.80/10. ==See also==