Initially, Loebe continued to work as a freelance audio engineer while performing at colleges and coffeehouses on the east coast of the US. She has said in interviews that she worked as an assistant engineer at Gallop Studios in Atlanta in between tour dates for over a year to barter time for the recording of her second full-length album
Mystery Prize.'. In 2010, Loebe's album, “Mystery Prize”, spent 10 weeks on the Americana Top 40 chart. She signed an album deal with European record label Continental Record Services. She was slated to perform on a European tour in the Spring of 2011 but the tour was canceled when she was cast on the first season of NBC's
The Voice. Loebe recorded and released
Circus Heart in 2012, produced by Austin songwriter
Matt the Electrician on the Black Wolf Records imprint. The album was funded by fans who pre-ordered the album off of her website.
Circus Heart was released in Europe by Continental Record Services. In 2013 Loebe toured nationally with folk songwriter
Ellis Paul. She also toured in Texas and Oklahoma with
Raina Rose and Smokey & The Mirror, and those shows were recorded by Virginia-based Americana label Goose Creek Music and was released as a 3-album live set in 2014. In 2014, Loebe led a creativity workshop and performed at
Yokota Air Base in
Fussa, Tokyo. Later in 2014, Rebecca performed in The Netherlands for the first time and has performed every year since. On her second tour of The Netherlands in 2015, she performed on
Voetbal Inside, a sports show hosted by Dutch football star
Johan Derksen.
Blink, her fourth full-length studio album, was released in 2017. Record label executive Denby Auble saw Loebe performing while on tour promoting the album and offered her a record deal on
Blue Corn Music. Loebe was mentioned as a new favorite musician of the character Morgan, in the 2018 New York Times Bestselling novel,
Leah on The Offbeat, written by
Becky Albertalli. In 2019, Loebe released her fifth full-length studio album,
Give Up Your Ghosts. Her single,
Growing Up was featured in Rolling Stone magazine listed as the
Top 10 Best Country and Americana Songs of the Week.{{cite magazine|url=https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/best-country-songs-to-stream-kassi-ashton-812778/ In November 2019, Loebe announced plans to celebrate the 10-year anniversary of her album “Mystery Prize": she planned an intimate, acoustic concert tour in 2020 where she was to re-visit songs and stories from the album. However, due to the
COVID-19 pandemic, those dates had to be postponed to 2022.{{cite web|url=http://www.bluedoorokc.com/2019/11/rebecca-loebe-mystery-prize-2020-tour-on-sun-february-9-2020/ In July 2021, ''Nobody's Girl
released their first full-length album, titled Nobody's Girl''.{{cite web|url=https://americansongwriter.com/review-nobodys-girls-self-titled-album/ ==Awards and recognition==