Keane resigned the day following the Cardinals'
1964 World Series victory over the Yankees, and Schoendienst was named as his replacement. Three years later, the Cardinals defeated the
Boston Red Sox—Schoendienst's fourth World Series title, and third as a Cardinal. The Cardinals repeated as champions of the National League in 1968 (the last year without divisions), but the
Detroit Tigers beat them in seven games to win the
World Series. For the rest of Schoendienst's tenure of managing a team now entrenched in the National League East, the Cardinals won ninety games just once (1971) and did not reach the postseason again, although they finished second three times in a four-year span (1971-1974). His managerial record over twelve full seasons (1965–76) and two subsequent stints as interim manager (1980 and 1990) was 1,041–955 (.522). After two years as a coach for the 1977–78
Oakland Athletics, Schoendienst returned to the Cardinals as coach and special assistant to the general manager. He won his fifth
Series title in
1982. He remained an employee of the Cardinals organization with the title of Special Assistant Coach, and in
2017 completed his 73rd consecutive season as a Major League player, coach, or manager. Schoendienst was a member of five winning World Series teams, all of which were won in seven games: as a player with the Cardinals and Braves in
1946 and
1957 respectively; as the Cardinals manager in
1967; and as a Cardinals coach in
1964 and
1982. He was also a member of three teams that lost the Series after leading three games to one: the 1958 Milwaukee Braves (to the Yankees), the 1968 Cardinals (to the
Detroit Tigers), and the 1985 Cardinals (to the
Kansas City Royals). ,
Busch Stadium In 1989, the
Veterans Committee elected Schoendienst to the
Baseball Hall of Fame. The Cardinals retired his
number 2 in 1996. In 1998 he was inducted into the
St. Louis Walk of Fame The Cardinals named Schoendienst, among 21 other former players and personnel, to be inducted into the
St. Louis Cardinals Hall of Fame and Museum for the inaugural class of
2014. The Milwaukee Braves Historical Association inducted Schoendienst into the Milwaukee Braves Honor Roll, located in
Miller Park, in 2015. ==Managerial record==