Her racing career was extraordinarily brief – and undefeated. She bested her America's Cup challenger, Sir
Thomas Lipton's Shamrock III, designed by
William Fife, in all three races, with
Shamrock III losing by such a margin in the third that she was forced to retire.
Reliances designer, Nathanael Herreshoff, immediately proposed the
Universal rating rule to avoid such extreme, dangerous and expensive vessels, which made
Reliance an inadequate contestant in subsequent races. There was much speculation as to whether
Reliances victory was due to the design of the yacht or the skill of Charlie Barr in sailing her. Lipton himself proposed to allow the two boats to swap crew after the race to decide the matter, but the offer was refused by the owners of
Reliance. Her very successful career was short-lived, and she was sold for scrap in 1913. ==References==