Recoil criticised the R51 for being unreliable and uncomfortable to shoot and operate. However, they praised its compact size and "inspired aesthetic", saying that "for a couple hundred bucks, this gun is totally worth it." Similarly,
American Rifleman complained of poor quality magazines which often failed to load properly, but noted its good accuracy and modest price.
The Firearm Blog was more critical, claiming that for a weapon of its size, a 7-round magazine capacity was too small, and it was much too difficult to
field strip: "taking the R51 apart for cleaning might be the worst experience of my life, but it's a one time affair. After you field strip the R51 for the first time, I promise you will either sell the gun, or just run it dirty until it kicks the bucket."
The Firearm Blog owed most of the R51's problems to its grip safety, which would pull the shooter's aim down and towards the right, and mentioned that the first 200 rounds were a "disgrace", with many malfunctions, including the magazine falling out, failure to feed, failure to extract and
stovepipes, and claimed "I don't think I've ever shot something that was quite so uncomfortable." == Generation 2 ==