Because of the limited availability of mammalian stomachs for rennet production, cheese makers have sought other ways to coagulate milk since at least
Roman times. The many sources of enzymes that can be a substitute for animal rennet range from plants and fungi to microbial sources. Cheeses produced from any of these varieties of rennet are suitable for
lactovegetarians, as well as those keeping
Kosher. Fermentation-produced
chymosin is used more often in industrial cheesemaking in North America and Europe today because it is less expensive than animal rennet.
Vegetable Many plants have coagulating properties.
Homer suggests in the
Iliad that the Greeks used an extract of
fig juice to coagulate milk. Other examples include several species of
Galium,
dried caper leaves,
nettles,
thistles,
mallow,
Withania coagulans (also known as Paneer Booti, Ashwagandh and the Indian Cheesemaker), and
ground ivy. Some traditional cheese production in the
Mediterranean uses enzymes from thistle or
Cynara (artichokes and cardoons). Phytic acid, derived from unfermented
soybeans, or fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC) may also be used.
Vegetable rennet might be used in the production of
kosher and
halal cheeses, but nearly all kosher cheeses are produced with either microbial rennet or FPC. Commercial so-called vegetable rennets usually contain an extract from the
mold Rhizomucor miehei described below.
Microbial Some molds such as
Rhizomucor miehei are able to produce
proteolytic enzymes. These molds are produced in a
fermenter and then specially concentrated and purified to avoid contamination with unpleasant byproducts of the mold growth. The traditional view is that these coagulants result in bitterness and low yield in cheese, especially when aged for a long time. Over the years, microbial coagulants have improved greatly, largely due to the
characterization and purification of secondary enzymes responsible for bitter peptide formation/non-specific proteolytic breakdown in cheese aged for long periods. Consequently, it has become possible to produce several high-quality cheeses with microbial rennet. It is also suitable for the elaboration of
vegetarian cheese, provided no animal-based ingredients are used in its production.
Fermentation-produced chymosin Because of the above imperfections of microbial and animal rennets, many producers sought other replacements of rennet. With genetic engineering it became possible to isolate rennet genes from animals and introduce them into certain
bacteria,
fungi, or
yeasts to make them produce
recombinant chymosin during fermentation. The genetically modified microorganism is killed after fermentation and chymosin isolated from the fermentation broth, so that the fermentation-produced
chymosin (FPC) used by cheese producers does not contain a GMO or any GMO DNA. FPC is identical to chymosin made by an animal, but is produced in a more efficient way. FPC products have been on the market since 1990 and, because the quantity needed per unit of milk can be standardized, are commercially viable alternatives to crude animal or plant rennets, as well as generally preferred to them in industrial production. Originally created by biotechnology company
Pfizer, FPC was the first artificially-produced enzyme to be registered and allowed by the
US Food and Drug Administration. In 1999, about 60% of US
hard cheeses were made with FPC, which thereafter made up to 80% of the global market share for rennet. By 2017, FPC had 90% of the global market share for rennet. The most widely used FPC is produced either by the fungus
Aspergillus niger and commercialized under the trademark CHY-MAX by the Danish company
Chr. Hansen, or produced by
Kluyveromyces lactis and commercialized under the trademark Maxiren by the Dutch company DSM. FPC is chymosin B, so it is purer than animal rennet, which contains a multitude of proteins. FPC provides several benefits to the cheese producer compared with animal or microbial rennet: higher production yield, better curd texture, and reduced bitterness. and halal, and are suitable for vegetarians if no animal-based alimentation was used during the chymosin production in the fermenter. == Nonrennet coagulation ==