Writing in
The New York Times, critic
John J. O'Connor reported that the protagonists "manage to get through the familiar array of car chases and other assorted thrills with their old deadpan sophistication intact," and "considering the passage of time, the two men are in remarkably good shape, although it's a touch difficult to believe grown, beautiful women cooing constantly about
Illya's blue eyes," concluding that "it's all cleverly concocted fantasy, as taxing as your average comic strip." Critic Paul Mavis wrote in
DVD Talk that the "iconic stars returned for this limp, unfocused comeback, but neither should have bothered, considering the end results," and "I was unfortunately reminded of the original series' wit and charm (as well as its wealth of serious/spoofy action) - elements all sadly lacking in this later lackluster affair," but noted that "when
[Robert Vaughn and
David McCallum] are on the screen together (and there are surprisingly few times that actually happens here - a big problem right there), it's obvious they're enjoying themselves, bouncing lines and knowing expressions off each other in a manner that approximates their previous duet act 15 years prior."
Norman Felton, who had served as a producer on the
original series, spoke positively of the film and observed, "
Return seemed to be written by an
U.N.C.L.E. fan who remembered certain things, and gave them a twist. There was a lot of freshness.". The series co-creator,
Sam Rolfe, was more negative in his assessment of the film saying it had no understanding of the underlying concept of the series. ==References ==