Critical response Film critic Emanuel Levy liked the film and wrote, "The movie became influential, launching a cycle of "reunion" films, which included
The Big Chill and the TV series
Thirtysomething. As a portrait of disenchantment,
Return was more authentic and honest than Lawrence Kasdan's star-studded
Big Chill...A rueful movie about unexceptional lives that have prematurely grown stale,
Secaucus is a bit commonplace, lacking genuine drama. But Sayles uses effectively a discursive, episodic format; he constructs strong scenes with resonant dialogue. The characters are complex and individually distinguished by speech, gesture, and manner." Critic Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat wrote, "Here's a nice little movie about the baby boom generation...Novelist John Sayles wrote, directed, and edited this movie. It is a labor of love. We watch these laidback individuals share their stories and reminisce about the past...But these baby boomers can't handle tension; the rift between Jeff and Maura sends tremors through the weekend. And although they put up a front of having a good time, one senses that things haven't turned out well for them — either in terms of meaningful relationships or in terms of personal fulfillment.
Return of the Secaucus Seven leaves one with a rueful feeling about this generation." The review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes reported that 81% of critics gave the film a positive review, based on sixteen reviews. Film critic
Aljean Harmetz of
The New York Times wrote in her review: "For a movie that cost $60,000,
The Return of the Secaucus Seven is traveling in heady company. Most $60,000 movies play at two film festivals, then end up on a 16-millimeter projector in their director's living room.
The Return of the Secaucus Seven, about seven antiwar activists who spend a weekend together 10 years later, was the surprise hit of last spring's
Los Angeles Filmex festival. The movie was also selected as one of the 10 best films of 1980 by
The Boston Globe,
The Los Angeles Times and
Time magazine, and last week it was nominated by the
Writers Guild as best comedy written directly for the screen. When it opened an unsuccessful commercial run in New York last September,
Vincent Canby, although expressing some reservations, praised the film as
sweet and engaging and
an honest, fully realized movie. Today it will try again, opening at the
Quad in
Greenwich Village this time."
Release Return of the Secaucus 7 was released in United States theatres on September 5, 1980.
Accolades Wins •
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Awards: LAFCA Award; Best Screenplay, John Sayles; 1980. •
Boston Society of Film Critics Awards: BSFC Award; Best Independent Film; 1981.
Nominations •
Writers Guild of America, East: WGA Award (Screen); Best Comedy Written Directly for the Screen, John Sayles; 1981.
Other distinctions • In 1997, the film was selected for preservation in the United States
National Film Registry by the
Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". ==
The Big Chill==