According to the
NPD Group,
Return to Mysterious Island sold 21,700 copies at a list price $19.99 by June 2005. It became Kheops Studio's biggest hit worldwide, which company head Benoît Hozjan attributed to
word of mouth. The game's later iPhone release sold 100,000 copies by November 2009.
Review aggregation website
Metacritic reported critical reception of
Return to Mysterious Islands original computer release as "generally positive", based on 19 reviews. The game 4 out of 5 from
Modojo for its iPhone version; the reviewer said that the game have remarkable visuals and audio as well as manageable inventory system but have frustrating puzzles.
Geek.com liked the game but also compared it to
Myst.
Return to Mysterious Island was nominated as
SME's pick for the best adventure game of 2004, but lost the prize to
Syberia II. In 2011,
Adventure Gamers named
Return to Mysterious Island the 53rd-best adventure game ever released. ==Legacy==