Resident Advisor stated that "
Returnal feels like a document as dazed and dizzy as heatstroke, the other-state peace of dehydration or exhaustion. But its emotional terrain is in constant flux—if, thankfully, slow to evolve—full of transitions and almost sullen mood-swings that make it, at various points, entrancing, bewitching and often quite perplexing." The publication stated that "
Returnal still seems like a lock for record of the year in a throwback genre expanding beyond cassette-collectors and Brain Records lovers."
Pitchforks
Philip Sherburne noted
Returnal to be more focused, thick and composite than Lopatin's past work, noting that when the synthesized
arpeggios common in his previous releases do come up, they are "layered and blurred to the point of losing their definition." Comparing
Returnal with Lopatin's previous works,
Tiny Mix Tapes described the album as "not just a collection of tracks but an indivisible and cohesive whole, held in place this time not by grids and zones but by atmospheres and plumes." ==Accolades==