Scott Churilla replaced Bentley as drummer in the mid-1990s, and the band released ''
It's Martini Time in 1996. The album brought the band its first Billboard chart success, The Reverend Horton Heat would release their final Interscope album, Space Heater'' (1998) Their sixth album,
Spend a Night in the Box (2000), was released through
Time Bomb Recordings, with
Paul Leary producing. The style was a return to straight-ahead rockabilly songs similar to their first two albums. The album rose through
CMJ charts to peak at number 2 in May. The song "Like a Rocket" was the theme for the
2002 Daytona 500 autosports race. The band featured the song on their seventh album,
Lucky 7.
Victory Records signed Reverend Horton Heat in 2012, and Scott Churilla returned to the band as drummer, playing for the next five years. An album titled
Rev was released on January 21, 2014. A
YouTube video for a single on the album, "Let Me Teach You How to Eat," preceded the album on November 12, 2013.
Rev rose to number 111 on the
Billboard 200, becoming the band's highest-charting album. The band toured as the opening act for
Motörhead, and recorded rock and roll songs with Motörhead's
Lemmy Kilmister, though the tapes are unreleased. Reverend Horton Heat also backed a number of other artists including
Unknown Hinson,
Jello Biafra, and
Deke Dickerson. In 2017, drummer Churilla was replaced by Arjuna "R.J." Contreras, formerly of the band
Eleven Hundred Springs. Matt Jordan of West Virginia joined the band playing piano and
organ as well as supporting vocals. They released the album
Whole New Life in 2018. In 2021, Heath and Wallace teamed with drummer
Slim Jim Phantom from the
Stray Cats to form a side project: The Jimbos. The trio was set to release a live album on called
Live In Houston on December 22, 2023. ==Commercial appearances==