Metcalfe was drafted by
Adelaide with their tenth selection and seventy-fourth overall in the
2016 AFL Women's draft, after requesting from the
Royal Australian Navy a posting in Adelaide and selecting South Australia as her preferred destination. She was a part of Adelaide's premiership side after the club defeated
Brisbane by six points at
Metricon Stadium in the
AFL Women's Grand Final. She played every match in her debut season to finish with eight matches. Adelaide signed Metcalfe for the
2018 season during the trade period in May 2017, and was the starting ruck in the 2018 season too. In a trial match against
Fremantle, ahead of the
2019 season, Metcalfe tore her left
anterior cruciate ligament, resulting in her missing the season and
Jess Foley filling her spot in the ruck. Despite her injury, she re-signed with the club for the
2020 season, kicking a goal in her return against
Carlton in round 4 of the season. She spent 2022 season 6 on the inactive list due to work commitments, following which she announced her retirement from the AFLW. ==Personal life==