In 2006,
Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a nonpartisan watchgroup founded in 2005 by
liberal and Democratic Party activists released a report naming Pombo as one of the 13 most corrupt members of Congress. Pombo issued a statement where he denied the allegations and described the group as "a liberal-activist organization masquerading as a government watchdog group."
Corruption allegations Pombo and his
political action committee RICH PAC was among a dozen leaders in the House of Representatives reportedly under investigation as part of the corruption and influence-peddling scandal centered around disgraced Washington lobbyist
Jack Abramoff, and his policy issues, including
Indian gaming. Pombo had accepted more money from Abramoff than had any other member of Congress ($500,000). Fundraisers organized by Indian gaming interests and tied to the 2005 MLB All-Star Game are among those activities under scrutiny. On January 8, 2006, the
Los Angeles Times alleged that Pombo helped one of Abramoff's clients, the
Mashpee Indians in
Massachusetts, gain federal recognition as a tribe. In return, Pombo received campaign contributions from both the tribe and Abramoff. In the 2006 cycle, Abramoff was one of the top donors to Pombo's political action committee. Several of Pombo's top five donors are political influence brokers from
Detroit, who hosted several $5,000-per-person fundraisers for Pombo in their
owners box at
Comerica Park during the 2005 MLB All-Star Game. News reports indicated contributions from the two-day fundraising event would go to RICH Political Action Committee. However,
Federal Election Commission reports filed by RICH PAC show only one such contribution. Apparently contributions were diverted to some other entity making it difficult to track who attended and contributed. The
Ilitch family, owners of the MLB
Detroit Tigers and Detroit's
MotorCity Casino, are also financial backers of various Indian tribes, including the
Shinnecock Indian Nation, which is seeking to build a gaming casino on its reservation near
Southampton, New York. Various issues and tribal disputes involving the Shinnecock were before the House Resources Committee chaired by Pombo just days after the fundraiser.
Freeways that could enhance owned real estate Various members of the Pombo family individually own more than undeveloped near two proposed freeways. If even one of the proposed freeways is eventually built, the value of the property owned by Pombo's relatives and located near the proposed freeway will be worth far more than its currently assessed value. Pombo led an effort to build a multilane
freeway (
State Route 130) through the mostly uninhabited
Diablo Range to facilitate
Bay Area-bound commuting from the greater Tracy area.
Windfarm regulations Pombo's home town of Tracy is close to a large
wind farm on
Altamont Pass. In 2004, Pombo's office sent a letter to then-Secretary of the Department of the Interior
Gale Norton, urging the suspension of environmental guidelines opposed by the wind power industry. Pombo's parents have received hundreds of thousands of dollars in royalties from wind-powered turbines on their ranch. Pombo owns an interest in his parents' ranch.
Payments to family Between 2000 and 2004, Pombo used his campaign and PAC funds to pay his brother Randall $272,000, and his wife (between 2003 and 2004) $85,000. In that 2003–04 campaign cycle, Pombo paid more to his family members—$217,000—than his opponent,
Jerry McNerney, spent on his entire campaign. The two were paid for duties listed as bookkeeping, fundraising, consulting and other unspecified services. After publicity about the payments to his family, Randall was taken off Pombo's payroll (total payments between January 2005 and mid-2006 were less than $7,000). Pombo's wife continued to be paid at the rate of $3,000 per month.
Mailings during 2004 campaign In October 2004, Pombo used the franking privileges afforded members of Congress to mail approximately 175,000 copies of a two-page leaflet that openly praised the House Resources Committee and the
Bush administration for overturning
Clinton Administration limits on snowmobiling in national parks. The leaflets were sent to snowmobile owners in the
swing states of
Wisconsin and
Minnesota. Pombo authorized the expenditure of $68,081 from House Resources Committee funds for the mailing of the leaflets as "official business." House members are required to seek prior approval and obtain advisory opinions before sending out franked mail; no such approval was obtained prior to the October mailing.
2003 RV trip charged to the federal government In August 2003, Pombo and his family rented an RV and "spent two weeks on vacation, stopping along the way to enjoy ... our national parks". The trip included stops in the
Grand Canyon,
Yellowstone,
Joshua Tree,
Sequoia National Park,
Kings Canyon National Park and
Mount Rushmore,
Badlands National Park, and other parks. The $4,935 cost of the rental was charged to the federal government, but was determined to be a more cost effective alternative to flying, renting a car, and staying in a hotel. When asked in February 2006 about the trip—rules forbid government-funded travel for personal vacations, but allow lawmakers to bring family members on official trips—Pombo said that he had looked into flying into the parks by commercial air or charters, but found the costs to be excessive. After choosing to travel instead by RV, he invited his family along with him. At
Yellowstone, Pombo had a lengthy meeting with the park superintendent, which a spokesman charactizered as official. Pombo's visit to the
Badlands National Park is in dispute: the secretary to the superintendent said he did not show; a spokesman for Pombo said that Pombo was certain he was there and met with a group of Native American tribal leaders nearby. Reports concerning Pombo's visit to
Joshua Tree are also contradictory. The
Los Angeles Times was told that Pombo had shown up for his meeting but "they were not there". The
Tracy Press was told that Pombo met with the park's acting superintendent. Officials from
Sequoia and
Kings Canyon national parks did not return calls seeking comment.
Investigation of Charles Hurwitz One January 8, 2006, the
Los Angeles Times reported that Pombo and Representative
John Doolittle had joined with then-House Majority Leader
Tom DeLay of
Texas to oppose an investigation by federal banking regulators into the affairs of
Houston millionaire
Charles Hurwitz. The
Times reported that "When the
FDIC persisted, Doolittle and Pombo—both considered protegés of DeLay—used their power as members of the House Resources Committee to
subpoena the agency's confidential records on the case, including details of the evidence FDIC investigators had compiled on Hurwitz." The investigation was ultimately dropped. According to the
Times, "Although Washington politicians frequently try to help important constituents and contributors, it is unusual for members of Congress to take direct steps to stymie an ongoing investigation by an agency such as the FDIC." The article concluded, "in the Hurwitz case, Doolittle and Pombo were in a position to pressure the FDIC and did so."
Corruption at the Interior Department On September 23, 2006, the Central Valley
Record reported that East Bay Representative
George Miller and six other House Democrats had requested that Pombo hold "immediate" congressional hearings concerning oil lease payments to the
Interior Department. The article noted that "Miller and his allies—including Pombo's challenger,
wind power consultant
Jerry McNerney—want oil companies such as
Chevron to renegotiate contracts they inked with Clinton administration officials that failed to include language requiring the firms to pay taxes when oil prices pass $36 a barrel." Pombo "had a provision written into the House's offshore drilling legislation, which passed earlier this year, that would instead levy a fee on those firms that refuse to renegotiate their contracts."
Probed oil firm linked to Pombo An
Alaskan oil services company under federal investigation in connection with allegations of influence peddling has contributed nearly $18,000 to Pombo. The investigation sparked a Washington state candidate for the Senate to return his contributions from
Anchorage-based
VECO Corporation the day after the
FBI raided offices of several Alaskan state legislators.
Environmental record as he signs the Partners for Fish and Wildlife Act into law Pombo proposed legislation to sell roughly a quarter of the land managed by the
National Park Service. In November 2005, Pombo and
Jim Gibbons (R-
NV) co-authored an amendment to the Federal Budget Reconciliation Bill easing restrictions of sale of federal lands to mining companies. This amendment was opposed by
environmentalists, anti-growth advocates, and even some Republican Senators concerned about the measure's effects on hunting and fishing. The amendment narrowly passed the House, but was defeated in the Senate. The legislation was later described by his chief of staff as a "bureaucratic exercise" designed to evaluate the costs of not drilling in the
Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR). Pombo supported oil drilling in the ANWR, despite concerns about the
ecosystem and opposition from moderate Republicans. In September 2005, Pombo helped write a revision of the 1973
Endangered Species Act. The proposed revision "was widely denounced by environmentalists as a disturbing retreat from habitat protection and a paperwork nightmare for agencies seeking to revive the 1,268 threatened and endangered plants and animals in the country, 186 of which are in California." The bill did not pass. By March 2006,
Environmental Science & Technology reported that Pombo was coordinating efforts with Pac/West Communications to weaken the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Pac/West created the
Save Our Species Alliance, an anti-environmental front group that campaigned for Pombo's bill to change the ESA. The
League of Conservation Voters, a nonpartisan
PAC, assigned Pombo a lifetime average rating of 7 on a scale of 0 to 100. In 2005, he scored a 6. Subsequently, the organization named Pombo as one of the "Dirty Dozen" in 2006. LCV released an ad on October 31, 2006, citing Pombo's acceptance of $120,000 from oil companies and his ties to indicted lobbyist
Jack Abramoff.
Rolling Stone ranked him one of the worst congressmen and called him "Enemy of the Earth". The
Sierra Club called him an "eco-thug". His political revival was characterized as giving environmentalists "fits" by the
San Jose Mercury News in addition to describing his perception by that community as similar to that of Exxon-Valdez
Captain Joseph Hazelwood or the hunter that shot
Bambi's mother. The
League of Conservation Voters added him to their Dirty Dozen list in 2010, even though this list is typically reserved for sitting members of Congress; and Warner Chabor, the organization's CEO, stated, "Having Pombo represent a district that includes
Yosemite National Park is like electing
Godzilla as mayor of
Tokyo". ==2006 re-election campaign==