Debra visits
Dexter to talk about the
Ice Truck Killer case. Afterwards, Dexter examines the
Barbie doll the killer left in his apartment and realizes the hands have differently painted fingernails. After giving evidence at a trial, he enters another courtroom where Matt Chambers (
Sam Trammell) is being tried for
manslaughter after drunkenly running over a teenager with his car. Dexter travels to a crime scene under the
Westbound Causeway, where he notices a piece of human flesh in the dead victim's mouth. At the station, Debra tells Dexter about her new boyfriend Sean. They make plans to have a lunch date along with Dexter's girlfriend
Rita. The victim at the causeway is discovered to be a police officer named Ricky Simmons.
LaGuerta and
Doakes go to his home, where they find his wife Kara injured but alive. While analysing the scene, Dexter finds a drop of blood that is not hers. Dexter tells Rita about the lunch date. Debra calls to tell Dexter she has found a
refrigerated truck with human fingertips inside, which have fingernails painted like the doll's. The bitten-off skin from Simmons' mouth is linked to
Norberto Cervantes, who is apprehended by Doakes after Cervantes meets with drug lord Carlos Guerrero. Under questioning, Cervantes claims Kara was having an affair; Doakes punches him. LaGuerta takes a blood sample from Cervantes to confirm the skin and blood was his. Meanwhile, Chambers testifies that his car was stolen hours before the teenager's death and that he has been sober for several months. Dexter and Detective
Angel Batista find more of Cervantes' blood at Kara's home. Dexter obtains Chambers's fingerprint and discovers that he has killed people while driving drunk in other states. He prepares his kill room before going on the double date. When Rita notices the apparent ease of Debra and Sean's relationship, she begins to feel insecure and Dexter has difficulty comforting her. Cervantes is killed in jail by a man
impersonating a police officer. Later, Rita and Dexter agree not to have sex until Rita is ready. Debra learns she is being promoted to Homicide. LaGuerta informs Doakes that Kara has died of
heart failure and forces him to admit that they were sleeping together, agreeing to keep the relationship secret so Doakes can remain on the case. Dexter sees Guerrero and contemplates killing him, but decides against it. He kidnaps Chambers, forces him to confess, then kills him and disposes of the body. At home, he finds evidence that the Ice Truck Killer has broken into his apartment for a second time. ==Reception==