The periodical never had a circulation above 20,000. It did not earn a profit, so after December 1870 the subscription list was absorbed into
Scribner’s Monthly, a new magazine for adults. In the last issue of the children’s periodical editor Horace Elisha Scudder wrote: “You have had the ‘Riverside’ for four years, and I believe you have enjoyed it, for I have not yet seen the boy or girl who ‘hates that old Magazine.’ I have seen a great many who like it thoroughly, and many pleasant letters from old and young make me believe it, whether I want to or not, and I want to. Now you will never have a fifth volume of the ‘Riverside,’ so enjoy the four! And I have had four or five years of pleasure, editing this Magazine. Nobody can take those away from me. I have made friends by it that I hope never to lose. I do not expect to edit any more magazines for young people, but I mean to enjoy the recollection of the days when I edited the ‘Riverside,’ and had the pleasure every month of seeing its bright cover flying away, with its treasure of story and verse and picture, to gladden the eyes of children whom I never should see. If the editors of ‘Scribner’s Monthly’ and my grown friends are as good friends as we have been, nobody could ask for more.” In 1874, more than three years after the periodical’s last issue had been published, a poll taken amongst readers of The Literary World ranked
The Riverside Magazine For Young People to be second amongst “modern American juvenile magazines.” == References ==