In the campaign trail of 1826, Vance accused his friend and competitor
Samuel Price Carson of taking money from the public while campaigning in Asheville. Vance made another remark in
Morganton about Carson's father's
Tory allegiance during the Revolutionary War. Silas McDowell quoted Vance: Following the remark, Carson challenged Vance to a duel in a letter he wrote at
Pleasant Gardens on September 12, 1827. He posted the letter from Tennessee to circumvent North Carolina laws against dueling. The duel was held in November 1827 at
Old Buncombe Road, Saluda Gap in South Carolina, just over the border from North Carolina. The
seconds for Carson were both General
Alney Burgin and Warren Davis. The second for Vance was General Franklin Patton.
Davy Crockett was said to be a witness to the duel, as a friend of Carson's. Vance was shot in the side. He was carried to a nearby hotel and died there the following day. He was buried in the family burial ground on Reems Creek. == See also ==