On January 18, 1984, John Loeman Jr., a 16-year-old boy, claimed to authorities that he had witnessed the murder take place. According to Loeman, he claimed that he had witnessed a woman named Janet Shatford use an axe to strike Leeman and saw Mailman use a
shotgun to strike him in the head. Loeman also claimed that Gillespie was also present, holding a gasoline-contained container. The following day, Gillespie and Shatford were arrested and charged with
second-degree murder. Shatford confessed and pled guilty to
manslaughter as part of a
plea bargain that saw her testify against Mailman and Gillespie. Loeman knew the three accused and had previously worked for Shatford as a babysitter; Gillespie was a previous boyfriend of Shatford's. The first trial against Mailman and Gillespie, which took place during March 1984, resulted in a
hung jury. During the following May, a new trial resulted in both of them receiving a
life imprisonment sentence for second-degree murder. Shatford was sent to a women's prison, where she served three years before being released. The only evidence used against Mailman and Gillespie were the testimonies from Loeman and Shatford. ==Exoneration==