Upon its release,
Robyn received general acclaim from most music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an
average score of 86, based on 17 reviews, which indicates "universal acclaim".
AllMusic editor Heather Phares called the album "a freewheeling, accomplished pop album that is so fresh that it could pass for a debut", and viewed it as "the pop
tour de force that Robyn has always had in her". Chris Willman of
Entertainment Weekly graded the album an A, referring to it as "hooky dance-pop greatness" and "[f]antastic all of the time". Barry Walters of
Spin stated that Robyn "flashes lyrical smarts that veer between wisecracking sass and heartbroken eloquence", and that the album "achieves the sort of pure pop perfection that her more mainstream records never did."
Rolling Stones
Will Hermes concluded, "Sexy without being pandering, arty without being pretentious,
Robyn is a public service: a record that can make indie-minded geeks dance without shame." Priya Elan of the
NME opined that the album "manages to piece together many of the elements of her chameleon-like career [...] and come up with what is the most inventive pop album you'll hear all year."
Slant Magazines Sal Cinquemani expressed that the album is "definitely a slow-burner [...], but it's also everything pop music should be: provocative, poignant, inventive, and fun." Daniel Rivera of
PopMatters cited the album as Robyn's "most honest and infectious outing to date" and noted that "the most impressive thing about
Robyn is just how timeless it is proving to be."
Stylus Magazine's Jessica Popper wrote that the album "manages to combine several of the currently popular music genres whilst still making a perfect pop album [...] It's one of the few
Europop albums that not only deserves worldwide domination, but also has a really good chance of achieving it." In a review for the
Manchester Evening News, Paul Taylor described the album as "undeniably sexy" and dubbed Robyn "a mini-
Madonna in the making".
Billboards Jill Menze commended the album for its "sassy and sweet dance pop gems". In his consumer guide for
MSN Music, critic
Robert Christgau commented that he was "[initially] disoriented by the hype for 'With Every Heartbeat' [...] But without that add-on, which does grow on you the way pop breakthroughs will sometimes, this 2005 EU release might never have materialized here to prepare the way for Robyn 2010". James Hunter of
The Village Voice complimented its "fast electro arrangements tending toward the geometric" and found that "[Robyn's] appeal is questionable when she tries to sound like an American rapper, but on tracks where she just sings [...] she gives Europop a swift Swedish energy and presence".
Pitchfork reviewer Jess Harvell felt that Robyn's "pop fun
is a bit knowing—she's 26 after all. But trust the Swedes. They know what they're doing with this sort of thing."
Accolades According to Metacritic,
Robyn was the tenth best-reviewed album of 2008, as well as the best-reviewed pop album of the 2000–09 decade.
Slant Magazine listed it as the second best album of 2008.
Entertainment Weekly ranked it at number four on its list of the 10 Best CDs of 2008, praising Robyn as "an autonomous, thrillingly eccentric dance diva capable of both wrenching techno ballads [...] and saucy, whip-smart kiss-offs".
Pitchfork, on its list of the Top 50 Albums of 2005, placed the album at number thirty-nine on its list and hailed Robyn as "one of the best things that happened to music this year that folks on the wrong side of the Atlantic never heard".
Pitchfork also included it at number sixty-eight on its list of The Top 200 Albums of the 2000s and stated that "[n]obody [...] made a more lovable pop album this decade than Robyn", describing it as "an indie-as-fuck fairytale: Freed from proto-
Mouseketeer teen-pop servitude and inspired by the Knife, Robyn experiments across genres, emotes from the heart, and gradually amasses a netroots fanbase." Aside from critics' lists, the album received a nomination for
Best Electronic/Dance Album at the
2009 Grammy Awards, but lost out to
Daft Punk's
Alive 2007.
Robyn was listed by
Pitchfork as the 68th best album of the 2000s, calling it the most "lovable album of the decade". ==Commercial performance==