Censorship On October 27, 1960, twenty days after the film opened in Italy, its release was blocked and the negative was seized after
Domenico Tardini, the
Cardinal Secretary of State, requested that Italian officials take action against "certain destructive films". It was decided that, unless four scenes, including the murder of Nadia, were cut, the film would be confiscated and the producer prosecuted. After negotiations, producer
Goffredo Lombardo agreed to darken the criticized scenes with filters, and two of these darkened scenes were later omitted entirely; Visconti was not informed of these changes. The deleted scenes were restored for later home video releases. It sold 10,220,365 tickets in Italy.
Critical response For
The New York Times,
Bosley Crowther, gave the film a positive review in which he praised the direction and acting: "A fine Italian film to stand alongside the American classic,
The Grapes of Wrath, opened last night... It is Luchino Visconti's
Rocco and His Brothers (
Rocco e i suoi fratelli), and it comes here garlanded with laurels that are quite as appropriate in this context as they are richly deserved... Signor Visconti has clearly conceived his film and that is what his brilliant handling of events and characters makes one feel. There's a blending of strong emotionalism and realism to such an extent that the margins of each become fuzzy and indistinguishable... Alain Delon as the sweet and loyal Rocco...is touchingly pliant and expressive, but it is Renato Salvatori...who fills the screen with the anguish of a tortured and stricken character. His raw and restless performance is overpowering and unforgettable...[and the] French actress Annie Girardot is likewise striking as the piteous prostitute."
Variety lauded the drama, and wrote: "With all its faults, this is one of the top achievements of the year in Italy... Scripting shows numerous hands at work, yet all is pulled together by Visconti's dynamic and generally tasteful direction. Occasionally, as in the near-final revelation to the family of Simone's crime, the action gets out of hand and comes close to melodrama. Yet the impact of the main story line, aided by the sensitive, expertly guided playing of Alain Delon as Rocco, Annie Girardot as Nadia, and Renato Salvatori as Simone, is great. Katina Paxinou at times is perfect, at others she is allowed to act too theatrically and off-key."
Stanley Kauffmann of
The New Republic wrote that he found the film "distended, sententious, ostentatiously frank, fundamentally trite, and thematically unsuccessful".
Retrospective reviews When the film was released in DVD format, critic Glenn Erickson wrote: "A major pleasure of
Rocco and His Brothers is simply seeing its portrait of life in working-class Milan in 1960. Beautifully directed in the housing projects and streets of the city, this is a prime example of a film which will accrue historical interest simply because it shows so much of how people lived and what places looked like (now) 40 years ago." Art historian
Timothy James Clark expressed in 2023 his admiration for the film, pointing out the fertile final shot:[O]ne of the things I admire about the end of
Rocco and His Brothers (1960) by Visconti, ... [is] in the end, [where] after the brothers’ agony in Milan, [it] is the Party member, the good brother, the upstanding family man who adjusts to industrial society - and in the final minutes you see him going off to his home in the suburb. In a sense, Visconti is saying that that is the ending. Aren’t the other brothers, the maladjusted brothers, all portrayed as crazed – as killers? But where does the movie leave you – dramatically, aesthetically? On the good brother’s side? Gian Luca Farinelli, president of the
Cinema Ritrovato film festival, shared that view:The final, extreme long-shot of Luca walking away from the gates of the Alfa Romeo factory and from the progressive speeches of his employed brother Ciro, seems to leave no doubt as to what Visconti really thinks: encapsulated in progress devoid of history, like the great Renaissance paintings we see entrapped inside the television screen, Italy, and what remains of the Parondi family, are moving towards a future without roots or beauty.
Martin Scorsese included the film on his list of "39 foreign films to see before you die", and
Francis Ford Coppola cited
Rocco and His Brothers as an inspiration for
The Godfather (1972). In 2008,
Roger Ebert added
Rocco to his "Great Movies" list. ==Awards and nominations==