Cash Box called "Rock and Roll Girls" a "pure rock celebration" and said that "Fogerty’s lead vocal is classic."
Rolling Stone Magazine critic Kurt Loder praised "Rock and Roll Girls" as "a rather spectacular demonstration of what can still be done with three shitty chords and a blazing sax.”
The Age critic Mike Daily described it as having "the breezy appeal of a
Buddy Holly song."
Allmusic critic
Stephen Thomas Erlewine rated it as a "terrific song," describing it as a "sunny rocker." Wawzenek rated the lyrics to "Rock and Roll Girls" among Fogerty's 10 greatest. Although less successful on the charts than Fogerty's previous single from
Centerfield, "
The Old Man Down the Road" which peaked at #10, "Rock and Roll Girls" reached the Top 20 on the
Billboard Hot 100, peaking at #20. It performed better on the
Billboard Mainstream Rock chart, peaking at #5, as well as in Canada, reaching #16, and in Austria, reaching #10. ==Lawsuit==