On the review aggregator
Metacritic,
Romanticize the Dive received a score of 75 out of 100 based on seven critics' reviews, indicating "generally favorable" reception. Joe Goggins of
DIY described it as sonically "leaning into the fundamentals", and
Under the Radar writer Jimi Arundell called it a "reaffirmation" of the band's most popular work. Eric B. Danton of
Paste said that despite its retrospective nature, it was not "merely a retread".
AllMusic reviewer Tim Sendra praised Haines' "second-to-none vocals", stating that it is "hard to image why she isn't a cultural icon on par with
Hayley Williams". == Track listing ==