Chicago Bears Smith was not drafted after graduating from Wisconsin. He asked the Chicago Bears owner and Hall of Fame coach
George Halas for a tryout, which Halas agreed to on a conditional basis in 1965. He was signed by the Bears defensive coach
George Allen, a future Hall of Fame head coach. Allen gave Smith guidance on how Smith could improve as a player through detailed observation and notation of the things he did right and things he did incorrectly. was in his rookie season at halfback. Halas offered to use Smith if he would play cornerback, and Smith agreed, again playing defense only sparingly for the Bears in 1965.
Atlanta Falcons Smith was left unprotected in the February 1966
expansion draft that provided players to the newly formed
Atlanta Falcons team for its inaugural season. The Falcons selected Smith (as well as Dan Lewis). During the 1966 preseason Smith proved himself to be one of the Falcons best defensive players, at
cornerback. He started all 14 games for the Falcons in 1966 at left cornerback, with two
interceptions. Smith led the NFL in both kickoff returns (43) and kickoff return yardage (1,013), including an 80 yard return. He also returned 11 punts for 80 yards. The 43 returns in a season were a then NFL record. Smith was not happy to hold that record as it meant both that he was playing on a bad team and his risk of injury increased. The 1966 Falcons' defense gave up the second most points in the NFL during that 14-game season (437), and gave up the most total yards (5, 272). In 1967, Smith led the NFL again in total kickoff returns (39) and total kickoff return yardage (976), though he suffered a leg injury that limited his playing time. He also returned 20 punts for 92 yards. The Falcons moved him to offense, where he started seven games as a
receiver. The Falcons believed this move would help
quarterback Randy Johnson by giving him a faster receiver. In the first game of the 1967 season against the
Baltimore Colts, Smith returned a kickoff 99 yards for a touchdown. He also had one pass reception in that game for 60 yards. On the season, Smith had 11 receptions (seventh best on the Falcons) for 227 yards (fourth best on the Falcons). He also had 42 rushing yards in eight carries. Smith was grateful and very pleased to be on a winning and close-knit team. Smith started 14 games at
strong safety for the Rams in 1968, with three interceptions. He returned 27 punts for 171 yards, and 26 kickoffs for 718 yards. His 27.6 yards per return average on kickoffs led the NFL. In the first game of the 1968 season, on a Monday night, Smith returned a kickoff 94 yards for a touchdown against the
St. Louis Cardinals. The Rams finished the season, 10–3–1. In 1969, Haymond led the NFL in punt return yards and average yards per punt return. He returned 16 kickoffs for 375 yards. Smith returned 23 punts for 122 yards (5.3 yards per return), and 27 kickoffs for 585 yards. Allen moved Smith to cornerback and he started 12 games in 1969, with three interceptions, including one for a 24-yard touchdown return against the Falcons in an early November game.
Return to Bears In early September 1970, Allen traded Smith and receiver
Jim Seymour (a former Rams No. 1 draft pick) to the Chicago Bears for defensive end
Dick Evey (a former Bears No. 1 draft pick) and a draft choice. Allen had been the Bears director of player personnel involved in drafting Evey. At the time, Allen said "'Smith did an excellent job for us as a kick returner and also played two positions. We'll miss him'". Smith started four games for the Bears in 1970, but his primary role was as a return specialist. He returned 33 punts for 126 yards, and 28 kickoffs for 651 yards. He returned kicks alongside
Cecil Turner, who had one of the best all-time seasons for a kick returner in NFL history. Turner tied the all-time record for touchdowns on kickoff returns in a seasons (4), and was second in the league that year with a 32.7 yards per return average. The Bears were 6–8 on the season. Smith had his best NFL season in 1972, when he was named to the Pro Bowl for the first and only time. He again started 14 games at strong safety, and had one interception; but it was as a kickoff returner that he excelled in 1972. He led the NFL with a 30.8 yards per kick return average (924 yards on 30 returns). He also returned 26 punts for 163 yards. In the final game of the 1972 NFL regular season against the
Oakland Raiders, Smith returned the opening kickoff 94 yards for a touchdown. The Bears' record on the season was 4–9–1.
San Diego Chargers and Oakland Raiders In May 1973, the Bears traded Smith to the
San Diego Chargers for a draft pick. Smith started nine games for the Chargers that season at strong safety, with one interception. He had his best season as a punt returner. He returned 27 punts for 352 yards, and his 13 yards per punt return average led the NFL. He returned two punts for touchdowns, also leading the NFL. In the second game of the season, against the
Buffalo Bills, Smith returned a punt 72 yards for a touchdown in the first quarter. In the Chargers second game against the Bills that season, on November 18, 1973, Smith had an 84-yard punt return for a touchdown, the longest punt return of the 1973 NFL season. This was the best team for which Smith played during his career, going 12–2 and reaching the
1974 AFC Championship Game where they lost to the eventual
Super Bowl IX Champion
Pittsburgh Steelers, 24–13. During the season, Smith had a career-high 41 punt returns. He averaged 11.9 yards per punt return (second highest of his career). In the AFC Championship Game, he had two kick returns for 42 yards. == Legacy ==