New York City FC Matarrita was signed to
New York City FC from
Alajuelense on 20 January 2016 for an undisclosed fee. Matarrita made his MLS debut against the
Chicago Fire on 6 March 2016. He scored his first goal for New York City during a 2–0 victory over
Seattle Sounders FC on 25 June 2016. After a strong first season, he was named New York City's Defensive Player of the Year for 2016.
FC Cincinnati On 29 December 2020, Matarrita was traded to
FC Cincinnati in exchange for $500,000 of General Allocation Money. He was released by Cincinnati following their 2022 season.
Aris On 20 June 2023, Matarrita joined
Super League Greece club
Aris on a three-year contract. ==International career==