As a freshman in
2010, Krautman hit 18 total field goals, tying the single-season school record, and was named Rookie Male Athlete of the Year. He also hit 16 consecutive field goals, which again tied the single season school record. At the end of the season, he was ranked 21st nationally and tied for second among
Big East kickers with 1.38 field goals per game. His 95% field goal percentage (18 for 19) led the conference. His numbers of total and consecutive field goals and field goal percentage tied three single-season Syracuse records held by
Gary Anderson. Because of his performance during his freshman season, Krautman was placed on the preseason watchlist for the 2011
Lou Groza Award. Krautman was the leading point scorer for Syracuse during the 2010, 2011 and 2012 seasons. In 2013, during his senior year, Krautman suffered a hip injury and didn't play for the remainder of the season. Following this, he received a medical waiver to return to Syracuse for a fifth year of eligibility. However, he retired from football before the 2014 season due to chronic effects of his injury. ==References==