John Shelton built Rural Plains in 1670. A subsequent John Shelton, the tavern keeper at Hanover Court House, was the father of
Sarah Shelton, who married the statesman
Patrick Henry in 1754. Shelton family, as well as popular lore, state that this marriage took place in the house's first floor parlor, though evidence cannot confirm this claim. Sarah's father gave Henry and her a wedding present of 300 acres of the Rural Plains property, which became known as
Pine Slash. This building, referred to as the "Honeymoon Cottage" still stands today a mile away from the Shelton House. During the
Battle of Totopotomoy Creek (the house stands 0.4 miles away from Totopotomoy Creek Union
signalmen climbed atop the house to convey messages to their troops. Confederate cannoneers tried to shoot them down, striking the building 51 times, but the signalmen survived. The scars of the damage remain today, but the Sheltons, who had sheltered in the basement during the battle, continued to reside in the house. The house was continuously inhabited by nine generations of Sheltons until the property was transferred to become part of Richmond National Battlefield Park in 2006. == Architecture ==