(1916) The German atrocities and the cultural destruction caused worldwide outrage. It greatly harmed Germany's standing in
neutral countries. In the United Kingdom, the prime minister,
H. H. Asquith, wrote that "the burning of Louvain is the worst thing [the Germans] have yet done. It reminds one of the
Thirty Years' War ... and the achievements of
Tilly and
Wallenstein." The
Irish Parliamentary Party, led by
John Redmond, condemned the German atrocities.
The Daily Mail called it the "Holocaust of Louvain". Intellectuals and journalists in Italy condemned the German act, and it contributed to
Italy distancing itself from Germany and Austria and drifting toward the
Allies. According to historian
Alfred-Maurice de Zayas, the War Crimes Bureau of the Prussian Ministry of War collected 73-eyewitness depositions about the Sack of Louvain, which were mainly from German officers and enlisted men. The original protocols, according to de Zayas, are more complete and more reliable than the excerpts appearing in
The German White Book. The depositions alleged that the German soldiers believed themselves to be under attack by armed Belgian civilians and that the destruction of the city and its cultural heritage took place in the heat of what was thought to be an urban battle against civilian-clothed members of the Belgian
Garde Civique. For example, it was alleged that the captured and slain insurgents were not recognized as local residents by any Belgians in Louvain, so they were thought to have been sent from outside the city with orders to stage an anti-German uprising. Furthermore, Georg Berghausen, the 1st Army's chief
medical officer, testified that the German soldiers wounded at Louvain had mostly been injured by bullets from hunting guns, rather than being the victims of
friendly fire. If Berghausen's testimony was not
perjury, in an effort to shield the officers and enlisted men of his Division from facing
court martial proceedings under
German military law, it is intriguing, as the city government of Louvain had ordered the confiscation of all privately owned firearms in early August, believing that civilian resistance was futile and would provoke violent reprisals. The university was reopened in 1919, and the reconstructed library was inaugurated in 1927. The rector of the university,
Paulin Ladeuze, said that "At Louvain, Germany disqualified itself as a nation of thinkers." More recently, 21st-century historian
Thomas Weber has examined the root causes of the
German war crimes committed during the
Rape of Belgium, the vast majority of which took place between 18 and 28 August 1914 and which were curtailed by the disciplinary policies the
Imperial German Army high command immediately adopted in response to the global outcry. Acting with the benefit of both hindsight and detachment from the emotions,
atrocity propaganda, and political ideologies of the period, Weber alleges that German war crimes in Belgium were not motivated by
anti-Catholicism, as even overwhelmingly Catholic units of the Imperial German Army willingly took part. They were also not, as many
Sonderweg thesis historians still allege, the natural outgrowth of both
German culture and
Prussian Army-style
militarism, from which a straight line can allegedly be drawn to
the Holocaust and the many other
Nazi war crimes of
World War II. Even though the
German people are
traditionally stereotyped as orderly, well-disciplined, and invariably super-efficient, according to Weber, the real, "situational factors at play", during the August 1914 Rape of Belgium were, "the nervousness and anxiety of hastily mobilized, largely untrained civilians, panic, [and] the slippery slope from
requisitioning to
looting and
pillaging." According to Weber, vast numbers of minimally trained, poorly disciplined, and extremely paranoid teenaged German soldiers in August 1914 Belgium saw, "
franc-tireurs everywhere, with lethal consequences. In many cases of
friendly fire directed by German troops on other German troops or on occasions when German troops could not work out the direction of enemy fire, the existence of illegal enemy combatants was immediately assumed with devastating and disastrous results. To make matters worse, the Belgian Garde Civique - the home guard - that had been deployed during the first few days of the war (and thus immediately prior to the eleven-day period in which most atrocities took place) did indeed not wear regular uniforms." The destruction of the university library, whether it was an act of poorly trained conscripts whose discipline had imploded, a deliberate act of cultural vandalism, or because, similarly to the
bombing of
Monte Cassino in 1944, the library buildings were believed to be in secret use for military purposes, still violated Imperial Germany's obligation, as a signatory to the
Hague Convention of 1907, that "in sieges and bombardment all necessary steps must be taken to spare, as far as possible, buildings dedicated to religion, art, science, or charitable purposes". For this reason, the
Treaty of Versailles, which ended the First World War, included a clause to strengthen protections for
cultural property under
international law. A monument was erected in Louvain's municipal square, overlooking a mausoleum with the remains of 138 victims of the sack. The monument features panels by
Marcel Wolfers depicting the atrocities that soldiers from the
German 1st Army perpetrated against the civilian population of Louvain following the collapse of their military discipline. The mausoleum was unveiled in 1925 by former
Supreme Allied Commander Marshal
Ferdinand Foch, before an audience that included
Queen Elisabeth and Cardinal
Désiré-Joseph Mercier. ==See also==