Upon its initial release in 2002,
Sadness Will Prevail received mixed critical reception. William York, of
AllMusic, gave the record two and a half stars out of five, questioning the album's low-end lacking mixing and critiquing what he refers to as "the abundance of filler on [the] two discs". Xander Hoose of
Chronicles of Chaos gave the album six and a half stars out of a possible ten, stating that Austin's performance on the album is "far below his capabilities" and criticizing his vocals and production work on the album. R. Temin of Blistering.com gave the album a thumbs down for its vocals, long runtime, and packaging, referring to it as "pretentious crap". Maelstrom Zine's Roberto Martinelli, on the other hand, praised the album and called it the group's "most diverse and complete effort".
Extreme metal fanzine Apeshit also gave the album a positive review, stating that
Sadness Will Prevail contained "the darkest, most miserable, schizophrenic suicidal sounds you're most likely find" and ending their review stating that it is "the most original, albeit miserable album in recent memory". Similarly,
BraveWords editor Chris Bruni called the album "one of the harshest, most insane releases [he's] heard all year". == Track listing ==