Some scientists, including
Kerry Emanuel and Lakshmi Kantha, have criticized the scale as being too simplistic, namely that the scale takes into account neither the physical size of a storm nor the amount of
precipitation it produces. Both of these scales are continuous, akin to the Richter scale. However, neither of these scales has been used by officials.
Proposed extensions After the series of powerful storm systems of the
2005 Atlantic hurricane season, as well as after
Hurricane Patricia, a few newspaper columnists and scientists brought up the suggestion of introducing Category 6. They have suggested pegging Category 6 to storms with winds greater than . Fresh calls were made for consideration of the issue after
Hurricane Irma in 2017, which was the subject of a number of seemingly credible false news reports as a "Category 6" storm, partly in consequence of so many local politicians using the term. Only a few storms of this intensity have been recorded. Of the 45 hurricanes currently considered to have attained Category 5 status in the Atlantic, 20 had wind speeds at or greater. Only 10 had wind speeds at or greater (the
1935 Labor Day hurricane,
Allen,
Gilbert,
Mitch,
Rita,
Wilma,
Irma,
Dorian,
Milton, and
Melissa). Of the 21 hurricanes currently considered to have attained Category 5 status in the eastern Pacific, only 5 had wind speeds at or greater (
Patsy,
John,
Linda,
Rick, and
Patricia). Only 3 had wind speeds at or greater (Linda, Rick, and Patricia). Most storms which would be eligible for this category were
typhoons in the western Pacific, where the scale is not officially used, most notably typhoons
Tip,
Halong,
Mawar, and
Bolaven in 1979, 2019 and 2023 (2 storms) respectively, each with sustained winds of , and typhoons
Haiyan,
Meranti,
Goni, and
Surigae in 2013, 2016, 2020 and 2021 respectively, each with sustained winds of . Occasionally, suggestions of using even higher wind speeds as the cutoff have been made. In a newspaper article published in November 2018,
NOAA research scientist Jim Kossin said that the potential for more intense hurricanes was increasing as the
climate warmed, and suggested that Category 6 would begin at , with a further hypothetical Category 7 beginning at . In 2024 another proposal to add "Category 6" was made, with a minimum wind speed of , with risk factors such as the
effects of climate change and warming ocean temperatures part of that research. In the NHC area of responsibility, only Patricia had winds greater than . According to Robert Simpson, co-creator of the scale, there are no reasons for a Category 6 on the Saffir–Simpson scale because it is designed to measure the potential damage of a hurricane to human-made structures. Simpson explained that "... when you get up into winds in excess of you have enough damage if that extreme wind sustains itself for as much as six seconds on a building it's going to cause rupturing damages that are serious no matter how well it's engineered." Nonetheless, the counties of
Broward and
Miami-Dade in Florida have building codes which require that critical infrastructure buildings be able to withstand Category 5 winds. New proposed scales include those based on factors other than peak wind speed alone. One proposal involves separate scales for wind, for storm surge, and for rainfall. ==See also==