The building was built as Church of the Holy Trinity, and opened in 1847. Following years of controversy, the parish was closed in 1957. The building stood mostly empty for the next 12 years. The present name of the parish reflects the fact that the congregation of St. Ann's, the oldest Episcopal parish in Brooklyn, moved into the empty Holy Trinity building in 1969. The church has some of the earliest figural stained-glass windows made in the United States, crafted by
William Jay Bolton. The church was declared a
National Historic Landmark in 1987. The designer for Holy Trinity was prominent 19th-century American architect
Minard Lafever, with stained glass by
William Jay Bolton and John Bolton. In 1859 English architect
Gervase Wheeler was hired to enlarge and make improvements in the chancel, such as modifications to the reading desk and adding pews; Wheeler was directed to follow the original plan in his work. A rectory was constructed immediately west of the church between 1895 and 1897. The ground floor of this building now serves as the parish hall. Following the departure of the
St. Ann Center for Restoration and the Arts in 1999, the church complex continued to lease school, office, programming, rehearsal and concert space to a wide range of community service and arts groups. However, in 2013, full-time tenants were moved out of the Parish House. ==St. Ann's Church (1787)==