Rating Saints and Soldiers was originally
rated "R" by the
MPAA, solely for war violence and related images. The director, writers, and producer wanted a "PG-13".
Some criticism has been leveled against the MPAA rating board with regard to their rating independent films more harshly than those of the large studios. (See also "
LDS cinema and MPAA ratings".) While the MPAA never communicated any specific scenes that warranted the rating,
Deseret News film critic Chris Hicks speculates that the reason may be due to two scenes, one in which depicts Nazis executing prisoners of war and another that shows a closeup of a leg wound. Producers made edits to receive the PG-13 for commercial distribution, and was officially granted such on March 30, 2004.
Saints and Soldiers represents the first LDS film produced after 2000 to be exhibited in film festivals before general release to gain publicity. It was the highest-grossing film released by Excel Entertainment, an entertainment section which targets an LDS audience. It grossed over $1 million.
Critical reception The reaction to
Saints and Soldiers was generally positive. The
Washington Times called the film, "one of the sharpest and most compelling entries of the early '
Mormon cinema' era".
The New York Times wrote that the film's, "impressive cast of largely unknown actors...[and] meticulously researched film tells its story with quiet conviction". However,
Variety insisted that the script had "letdowns", including
anachronisms in the dialogue and other story incongruities, yet they commended the production value considering the film's low budget.
Roger Ebert of
The Chicago Sun-Times gave
Saints and Soldiers 3 stars out of a possible 4, writing it “isn’t a great film, but what it does, it does well". He complimented the straightforward storytelling and creative use of its limited budget which were reminiscent of war films from earlier decades: "[the film] could have been made in 1948. That is not a bad thing." Ted Fry in
The Seattle Times added that "the film is intended as a propaganda piece for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but the messages are very subtle, and the movie does have a place in the new WWII genre", and is "appropriate for mainstream audiences". Furthermore, scholar Travis T. Anderson, affirmed that films made by LDS filmmakers such as
Saints and Soldiers and
Napoleon Dynamite can still develop "widespread attention" or "critical acclaim". He continued by stating that neither appeals to an exclusively LDS audience nor alienates non-LDS audiences. Moreover, scholar
Terryl Givens argued that
Saints and Soldiers can be interpreted specifically or universally. Givens claimed that the screenwriting created a film that is authentically Mormon yet reaches to a myriad of audiences. Although ties to Mormonism in the film have been criticized by some, Gideon O. Burton called the film, "among the most-praised films of the Fifth Wave [of Mormon cinema] to date".
Home media Saints and Soldiers was released on video and DVD in May 2005. ==Legacy==