In the
Deipnosophistae,
Athenaeus mentions a Salpe as the writer of
Paignia. He cites Nymphodorus of Syracuse, probably writing in the third century BC, as claiming that Salpe, the writer of the
Paignia, was not a nickname for a Mnaseas, but was a woman from Lesbos. The
Paignia is generally considered to have been a work of pornographic or erotic literature. Athenaeus associates the work with Botrys of Messana, a fifth-century author described as a "shameful writer" by
Timaeus. Botrys' work was apparently similar to the pornographic sex-manual attributed to
Philaenis. The work was probably written in prose, as Botrys' earlier
paignia had been. James Davidson argues that the Salpe mentioned by Athenaeus and the one cited by Pliny are likely to have been the same person. David Bain has argued against Davidson's suggestion, and I. M. Plant distinguishes between the two in his anthology of ancient women writers. More recently, Rebecca Flemming writes that "despite Bain's objections it remains tempting" to link Pliny's and Athenaeus' Salpe; she suggests that the original
Paignia referred to by Athenaeus was the original source of Pliny's recipes, though he would have read them second-hand (or "more probably third- or fourth-hand"). ==References==