After settling in Yerba Buena, Brannan consulted with natives who were familiar with the region and decided that the land down by the Sacramento River, which they named "New Hope", would be the next Nauvoo of the Mormons, but with real refuge and religious freedom. After disputes between members over land and other affairs, the city of "New Hope" quickly failed. In June 1847, Brannan traveled overland to
Green River,
Wyoming, to meet with
Brigham Young, the head of the
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, who was leading the first contingent of
Mormon pioneers across the plains to the
Great Basin region. Brannan urged Young to bring the Mormon pioneers to California as was previously planned, but Young rejected the proposal in favor of settling in what is present-day
Utah. Brannan returned to northern California frustrated with how the meeting had gone.
San Francisco and Sacramento In 1848, Brannan decided that he was going to use all of his resources in order to help build up California and its connection with the east. He planned on building that connection through the
California Star Express, which would deliver mail from San Francisco to
Independence, Missouri, and had its first route on April 1, 1848. In a few accounts of Brannan's dealings with the LDS Church it is said that Brigham Young sent the apostle
Amasa Lyman to collect the tithing money that Brannan had withheld from the church's institution. When Lyman arrived, Brannan was unable to account for the tithes that Brigham Young and other Mormons claimed were given to him or that he owed from his own personal income. He reportedly told them, "You go back and tell Brigham Young that I'll give up the Lord's money when he sends me a receipt signed by the Lord", although historians, such as
Will Bagley, have found that this is likely just legend. In another account, Lyman was sent to gather $10,000 of owed tithing from Brannan (or more if he was willing). After a couple of visits all of Brannan's debts to the LDS Church were considered to be paid in full. In order to continue the settlement of the west, Brannan purchased California's first steam locomotive in an effort to hasten the building of the first western railroad. He also teamed up with other local capitalists to construct the first wharf in San Francisco. Around this same time, Brannan made known his feelings about slavery and spoke out against it. On August 25, 1851, he was disfellowshipped from the LDS Church for "a general course of unchristianlike conduct, neglect of duty, and for combining with lawless assemblies to commit murder and other crimes." Anecdotes claim that in 1858, Brannan paid $1,500 (~$ in ) for lumber salvaged from a ship that foundered in waters near San Francisco, and on the basalt the headlands of the
San Francisco Peninsula overlooking the mouth of the
Golden Gate. The story further claims that he used the material to build the first
Cliff House, which is a popular restaurant and recreational area. There is no historical evidence to support this claim.
Calistoga After Brannan visited the
hot springs in the upper
Napa Valley in 1859, he planned a new resort for the area. He bought land containing the springs in the northern portion of the
Rancho Carne Humana in 1861 and founded the town of
Calistoga, said to be a combination of the words "California" and then-fashionable
Saratoga Springs in New York. Brannan also founded the
Napa Valley Railroad in 1864 in order to provide tourists with an easier way to reach Calistoga from the
San Francisco Bay ferry boats that docked in the lower Napa Valley at
Vallejo. The railroad was later sold at a foreclosure sale in
Napa County in 1869. Many poorer Calistoga residents were angered by Brannan's take-over of the region. At one point the opposition was so intense that Brannan was shot eight times. Brannan survived, but used a cane for the rest of his life. In 1870, Anna Eliza Corwin divorced Brannan. They had grown apart as Eliza lived in Europe for quite some time while Brannan remained in California. In the aftermath of the divorce, the judge ruled that his wife was entitled to half of their holdings in cash. The majority of Brannan's holdings were in real estate and he had to liquidate the properties to pay the full divorce settlement. ==Later years, death, and legacy==