In 2014 a recall campaign began against Fall River Mayor
William A. Flanagan, motivated by layoffs in the Fire Department and the start of a 'pay as you throw' trash collection program. After the recall campaign started Fall River City Councilor
Jasiel F. Correia, II accused Flanagan of threatening him with a gun, prompting DA Sutter to appoint a special prosecutor. The recall campaign was successful and forced a two-part recall election on December 16, 2014. The ballot voters got asked two questions: first, whether or not to recall Flanagan; and second, to vote for a mayoral candidate, which could still be Flanagan. Sutter was one of eight candidates on the
recall election ballot, and received about 6,000 votes, with incumbent Mayor Flanagan coming in second with about 4,400 votes defeated incumbent. Sutter's victory was the first successful recall of a mayor in the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Sutter was sworn in as Mayor of Fall River on December 30, 2014. Sutter faced another election in 2015, the regularly scheduled city elections. Sutter was challenged by Fall River City Councilor Jasiel Correia, who played a very public role in the effort to remove former Mayor Flanagan. According to Flanagan: “The gun incident became an international story. And locally, it was in the newspaper and on the radio, so yeah, the gun allegation gave Jasiel a platform.” On November 2, 2015, Sutter lost his bid for reelection to Correia, with Sutter receiving 7,621 votes, and Correia receiving 8,268 votes. Correia went on to be indicted on federal corruption and fraud charges, and faced his own recall election in March 2019, which Sutter declined to run in. Correia was recalled, but got the most votes in the second round of voting so he remained Mayor. Correia faced the voters again in the regularly scheduled 2019 elections, where he lost to Paul Coogan. Sutter also declined to run in the regular 2019 election. On December 28, 2022, Sutter announced he would run for Mayor again, challenging incumbent Mayor Paul Coogan in the 2023 mayoral election. On November 7, 2023, it was announced that Sutter had lost the election, receiving only 4,310 votes in comparison to Coogan's 6,643 votes. ==Personal life==