Israel pled guilty and on April 14, 2008, was sentenced to 20 years in prison and ordered to forfeit $300 million to compensate victims. He was allowed to remain free until being sent to prison, due to pre-existing medical issues that needed treatment. Israel and his girlfriend were featured on ''
America's Most Wanted''. Israel's girlfriend, Debra Ryan, was arrested later that same month for aiding and abetting his escape, and was released on bail. Ryan admitted to helping Israel escape, and also stated she and Israel parked an
RV loaded with Israel's belongings near Bear Mountain Bridge on the day before his disappearance. Israel surrendered to authorities on July 2, 2008 at the police station in
Southwick, Massachusetts. As a consequence, he was further sentenced on July 15, 2009, to an additional two years in prison while his girlfriend was sentenced to three years' probation. Israel is serving his sentence at
Federal Correctional Institution, Butner Low in
Butner, North Carolina. In 2019, he applied for early release, citing the
First Step Act. This application was denied, and Israel's scheduled release date is May 10, 2026. Israel has cited onging chronic health problems in his bids for compassionate early release. His requests were denied in 2014 and 2019. Judge
Colleen McMahon agreed in her 2019 ruling that Israel's health was poor, but she also said early release would "make a mockery of the sentencing statute" if Israel were released early, furthermore objecting to lenient sentencing for "white-collar criminals who have privileged backgrounds". ==In popular culture==