On 1 January 2015, Street was appointed to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, now the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, by the Attorney-General
George Brandis. In late 2015, statistics were filed in court which revealed Street had heard 254 migration appeals between January and June 2015, and had found in favour of the immigration minister in 252 cases (99.21% of cases). In that same period, Street disposed of 286 cases while his eight judicial colleagues disposed of a combined 357 cases. Street was accused of lacking procedural fairness and over 80 of his rulings were subsequently overturned in five years. Similarly, many of his judgements were delivered
ex tempore (literally, "on the spot") without taking further time to consider cases more deeply. In another case report from 2019, after an
ex tempore decision, he took 75 days to provide written reasoning for his dismissal of an Iranian asylum seeker's application to review a visa rejection, when the litigant had only 21 days to appeal. In 2022, Street was criticised for displaying bias in a bankruptcy dispute. ==References==