1997–1999: Three Chords and the Truth and early success produced Evans's debut album.|alt=Country music artist Pete Anderson, playing an electric guitar onstage Evans quit her job following the signing of her contract. She chose to have her album produced by
Pete Anderson, a producer and guitarist best known for his work with
Dwight Yoakam. To record the album, she moved to
Los Angeles. In July 1997,
Three Chords and the Truth was released on RCA.
Allmusic's James Chrispell positively commented, "This disc rings out with an air of originality helped along by great tunes and solid backup musicianship."
Billboard commented, "At once a preserver of the best of country's history and a progressive writer and singer forging a timeless contemporary country sound, she invites favorable comparisons to the best country divas." However, the album was not commercially successful. Its three singlesin order of release,
True Lies,
the title track, and "
Shame About That"peaked outside the
Billboard country songs top 40. The project peaked at number 11 on the
Billboard country albums chart. The disc became Evans's breakout album, certifying double platinum by the
Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) for sales of over two million copies in the United States. Critic Thom Jurek took notice of the record. He described Evans as having the "confidence and authority of a seasoned veteran who is in control of her work."
Born to Fly peaked at number six on the
Billboard country albums chart Four singles were released from
Born to Fly. First was the
title track, which Evans co-wrote with
Darrell Scott and
Marcus Hummon. This reached the number one spot on the
Billboard country singles chart and number 34 on the Hot 100. Next was a cover of
Edwin McCain's "
I Could Not Ask for More", followed by "
Saints & Angels" and "
I Keep Looking", the latter a top-five country hit in 2002. The
Academy of Country Music Awards also nominated her for Top Female Vocalist. With her new success, Evans joined
Reba McEntire,
Martina McBride,
Jamie O'Neal, and
Carolyn Dawn Johnson on the all-women headlining Girls Night Out Tour in 2001. In August 2003, her fourth studio album
Restless was released, with Evans and Worley continuing to co-produce.
Restless was met with mixed reviews. Writer Edward Morris described it as being "more pop than country in sound and attitude". James Christopher Monger found it to be "slick and predictable".
Restless debuted at number three on the Top Country Albums chart reached number 20 on the
Billboard 200 While the lead single "
Backseat of a Greyhound Bus", reached the top 20, its second single, "
Perfect", climbed to the number two spot on
Billboard country chart. It became her third number one song on the
Billboard country chart. The fourth and final single "
Tonight" was less successful, peaking outside the top 40 of Hot Country Songs in 2005. In 2005, Evans released a cover of
Radney Foster's "
A Real Fine Place to Start". It became her fourth number one song on the
Billboard country survey Sue Keough of
BBC called it "the perfect balance between radio-friendly country pop and the rootsy sounds she offered with her 1997 debut
Three Chords And The Truth." Meanwhile,
Slant Magazine's Jonathan Keefe gave it 2.5 stars, calling its notoriety in her catalog "less than essential". Despite mixed reviews, the disc was her first to top the
Billboard country albums chart. Evans moved her family to
Beverly Hills, California where the show rented her a home while she competed on the program. "It was absolutely exhausting and totally invigorating at the same time," she reflected in her memoir. At the same time, Evans's marriage to husband Craig Schelske was ending. The stress in her personal life caused Evans to suffer from anxiety and panic attacks. A month following her first appearance, she announced her departure from the show after filing for divorce from Schelske. "I had to quit working altogether, focus on my children, and really figure out what I was going to do," she later explained. Evans's divorce received widespread media attention between 2006 and 2007. These personal events delayed plans for the recording of a studio album for several years. However, Evans did continue to sporadically release new music. AllMusic's Thom Jurek gave the album three stars, criticizing its production and choice of material. Three of its new songs were released as singles. Its lead single "
As If" reached number 11 on the
Billboard country songs chart. It was followed by the top 40 entry "
Some Things Never Change". Later that year, she co-hosted the Country Music Association Awards. In May 2008, Evans appeared on
CMT Crossroads, a music show on
CMT which paired country music artists with pop music artists for collaborative performance. On her episode, she collaborated with pop band
Maroon 5 to sing songs from both artists' catalogs. In September 2008, Evans recorded the theme song to film
Billy: The Early Years. Released as a single, "
Low" briefly charted on the Hot Country Songs chart. Evans's next single was "
Feels Just Like a Love Song", which only peaked at number 59 on the country songs chart.
2010–2015: Comeback and career re-launch with Stronger In 2010, Evans collaborated with author Rachel Hauck to write
The Sweet By and By. Its follow up book,
Softly and Tenderly, was released in January 2011. Both novels focused on Christian themes and the main characters explored their religious relationships. Evans also returned to music in 2011. She enlisted record producer
Nathan Chapman to help re-launch her career. It was issued as a single in 2010 and topped the
Hot Country Songs chart in 2011. "A Little Bit Stronger" became her first number one single since 2005 and spent two weeks at the top.
Stronger later certified gold in the United States. The duo continued touring through 2012. Also in 2011, "A Little Bit Stronger" was nominated for Single of the Year by the Country Music Association Awards. The program also nominated Evans for Female Vocalist of the Year. Evans also sang the
National Anthem at Game two of the
2012 NBA Finals. Evans also sang the National Anthem at the start of Game 2 of the
2015 World Series between the
Kansas City Royals and the
New York Mets. In November 2012, Evans went back into the recording studio alongside Mark Bright to prepare for her next album project. A year later RCA released the single "
Slow Me Down". According to Evans, the single required more promotion due to the popularity of
Bro-country which had taken chart positions away from women. "I did something like forty-four free shows that year, on top of my regular touring dates," her memoir recalled. Nevertheless, "Slow Me Down" peaked in the top 20, Her seventh album of the
same name was released in March 2014 on RCA. and ranked number ten on
Billboard's "Best Country Albums of 2014". In October 2014, Evans appeared on ABC's
Nashville, playing herself. She performed a duet version of her next single, "
Put My Heart Down", with
Will Chase, who performed in-character as Luke Wheeler. Evans herself helped inspire the creation of the series lead
Rayna Jaymes, as the writers consulted with her about her experiences as a working mother in the country music industry so that Rayna's character would come across as authentic. In November 2014, Evans released her first full studio album of
Christmas music titled
At Christmas. In August 2015, Evans made a second appearance on
CMT Crossroads, this time performing alongside rock band
REO Speedwagon.
2016–present: New record label and career transition After spending her entire recording career on RCA, Evans left the label in February 2016. Six months later, she announced that she would be signing a contract with
Sugar Hill Records. However the label underwent a restructuring and Evans ultimately decided to leave the contract. In the same year, Evans appeared on the season finale of
USA Network's
Chrisley Knows Best. She performed a new track called "Infinite Love". The song was a duet with one of the show's cast members,
Todd Chrisley. A recording by the pair appeared in 2016 that charted in the top 40 of the
Billboard country chart. Evans had become increasingly frustrated with the country radio's lack of support for female artists. "No one seemed to respect all my previous success that I'd worked years to achieve," she recalled in her memoir. The frustration prompted Evans to launch her own label titled Born to Fly Records.
Sony RED partnered with the label to distribute the company's music. "Now I'm in the driver's seat, and every decision is made between my managers and me," she commented. The label released
Words, her ninth studio record, in July 2017. AllMusic's
Stephen Thomas Erlewine commented that, "
Words offers a sharp and welcome contrast to the bustling digital era." Mark Kennedy of the
Associated Press praised the album and concluded, "Artistic freedom has never sounded so good."
Words peaked at number four on the
Billboard country albums chart In 2019, Evans collaborated with her son and daughter to release an EP named
The Barker Family Band. The project featured harmonies from Evans and her children performing covers of songs by
Aretha Franklin and
Fleetwood Mac. A corresponding
live album was recorded at City Winery in
Nashville. Both projects were promoted through a mini tour that included five show dates in May 2019. In May 2020, Evans released her tenth studio project titled
Copy That. The project was a collection of classic country and
pop covers from different decades. Meanwhile, Jeffrey B. Remz of
Country Standard Time found it to be "just too syrupy" in his review. In September 2020, Evans released a memoir that discussed highlights from her life and career. The book was published by
Howard Books. In 2023, Evans competed in
season nine of
The Masked Singer as "Mustang". She was eliminated during the season premiere alongside
Dick Van Dyke as "Gnome". During this time, Evans stated that she started working on her next studio album that resembled
neotraditional country sound. In 2023, Evans signed with Melody Place Records. The same year she accepted an invitation to become an official member of the
Grand Ole Opry. Her first Melody Place album was issued in June 2024 titled
Unbroke. The project chronicled her marital conflicts and reconciliation with her second husband. The album's lead single "Pride" was issued in March 2024. Evans also created her own podcast titled
Diving in Deep with Sara Evans which was also released in spring 2024. ==Artistry==