Hutchings performed in various regional productions at the Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma, including
Buddy: The Buddy Holly Story,
Oliver!,
Hairspray,
Ragtime, and
A Chorus Line, where she played Diana Morales. Starting December 13, 2011, Hutchings made her Broadway debut as a swing in the musical
Memphis at the
Shubert Theatre, remaining with the show until it closed on August 5, 2012. From March 11 to December 22, 2013, Hutchings performed as a swing and originated the roles of Claudette Robinson, Billie Jean Brown, and Marvelette in the Broadway production of
Motown: The Musical at the
Lunt-Fontanne Theatre. Hutchings was also in the ensemble and played Apollo Girl in the original cast of the Broadway production of Rocky'' at the Winter Garden Theatre from February 13 to August 17, 2014. In 2016, Hutchings guest-starred as Ariel Rice in one episode of the
CBS series
Blue Bloods. From September 27 to October 29, 2017, she played Kathy Selden in the ZACH Theatre production of Singin' in the Rain in Austin, Texas. In 2017, she made her film debut as a secretary in The Vanishing of Sidney Hall and made a guest appearance as Amelia in the Netflix comedy series Master of None. From March 19, 2019, to January 19, 2020, Hutchings understudied the roles of Ado Annie Carnes, Laurey Williams, and the lead dancer in the 2019 Broadway revival of the musical
Oklahoma!. The revival won the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Musical in 2019. She has also made television guest appearances as a dancer in an episode of the FX miniseries Fosse/Verdon in 2019 and as Colleen in an episode of Freeform comedy series The Bold Type in 2020. Hutchings plays the role of Cowgirl on the 2024
concept album by
Lin-Manuel Miranda and
Eisa Davis,
Warriors. == Personal life ==