Critical response Upon release, "Save the Best for Last" received positive reviews from
music critics, while
Lynn Norment of
Jet called it "wonderful".
Larry Flick of
Billboard stated its production and orchestration "Proves that [Williams] is possibly best suited to such soothing fare, as her crystalline voice is caressed by soft and wafting strings". Mike Joyce of
The Washington Post named it the album's most radio-friendly track, and Arion Berger of
Entertainment Weekly declared it a show-stopper. Dave Sholin of the
Gavin Report opined, "while Vanessa is by now accustomed to chart success, this effort takes her to a whole new level" and "deserves to become her biggest hit to-date". For the same publication, John Martinucci said the singer "Gives this beautiful ballad a simple and delicate presentation that'll lift any romantic spirit". C.J. of
The Minnesota Star Tribune described it as "the most beautifully constructed, lyrically perfect love song to a stupid man ever recorded". Other reviewers focused on Williams' vocal performance. While deeming "Save the Best for Last" the album's centerpiece, R. LaMont Jones Jr. from
The Pittsburgh Press called it a song where Streisand would envy but "hard to imagine anyone doing it better" than Williams. Steve Pick from
St. Louis Post-Dispatch described Williams' phrasing and
dynamics as on par with experienced
jazz singers. Randy Clark and Bryan DeVaney of
Cashbox said the ballad is "Beautifully sung by Williams and tastefully produced and arranged by Keith Thomas".
AllMusic’s Michael Gallucci wrote that “Save the Best for Last” corrected the early decision to mask Williams’ perceived vocal limitations with heavy production on
The Right Stuff, demonstrating that, when given suitable material, she was capable of delivering a confident and effective vocal performance. Chris Rizik of
SoulTracks said her "slight but tonally beautiful voice was perfect for the song, and her standout performance made 'Save the Best' one of the year’s best and biggest singles". Some critics suggested that the song contributed to Williams’ recovery from her Miss America abdication. In December 1992,
Entertainment Weekly named Williams one of its “Entertainers of the Year”, with writer Mark Harris noting that the success of “Save the Best for Last” helped render the Miss America controversy irrelevant. Some critics offered more lukewarm assessments, describing the song as serviceable but largely generic. In 2021, Peter Piatkowski of
PopMatters said the song's "overproduced yet still perfect" production is balanced by Williams' vocals.
Stephen Holden called it "mostly generic" despite being well-made. For AllMusic, Tim Sendra called it a "smooth and somewhat saccharine" ballad. Scott Shetler of Total Music Awards called it "a fairly plain song with a decently warm melody and one of the better performances of Vanessa Williams’ career". Music historian David Freeland labeled it "plush, if unchallenging, pop music" which camouflaged with but was more restrained than the work of her peers,
Mariah Carey and the late
Whitney Houston.
Grammy Award for Song of the Year,
Record of the Year, and
Best Pop Vocal Performance, Female. That
same year, at the
Soul Train Music Awards, the song was nominated for
Best R&B Song of the Year and
Best R&B/Soul Single – Female. For recording "Save the Best for Last", Williams won the
NAACP Image Award for
Outstanding Female Artist at the
25th NAACP Image Awards in 1993.
Insider featured "Save the Best for Last" in their list of the "Best Songs from the '90s" in 2019, declaring it as "a gorgeous ballad", that "has stood the test of time."
Elle ranked it among "the Best Love Songs of All Time". ==Commercial performance==