Critical response Say Nothing received generally positive reviews from critics. It holds a 93% approval rating from 46 critics and an average rating of 8.5/10 on review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes. The critics consensus on the website states, "All the more powerful for its moral and political ambiguity,
Say Nothing is a haunting depiction of The Troubles." On
Metacritic, the series has a "generally favorable" reception based on a weighted average score of 80 out of 100 from 23 critics. Benji Wilson of
The Daily Telegraph gave
Say Nothing a grade of five out of five, describing it as a powerful blend of history, tragedy, and thriller, effectively weaving together multiple narratives that span four decades of the Troubles in Northern Ireland. He praised the series for its compelling portrayal of key figures like Gerry Adams, Jean McConville, Dolours Price, and Brendan Hughes, noting their strong performances and well-developed storylines. Wilson acknowledged the challenge of adapting Patrick Radden Keefe's 2018 book but commended the show for capturing its essence. He pointed out that the series initially romanticizes the IRA but later shifts to a more profound reflection on the past, with the inclusion of interviews from the Belfast Tapes. He highlighted the theme of the need for reconciliation and the tension between silence and truth, particularly through the character of Gerry Adams.
Viewership The streaming aggregator Reelgood, which tracks 20 million monthly viewing decisions across all streaming platforms in the US, calculated that
Say Nothing was the seventh most-streamed series in the US from November 14—20. It moved to ninth place for the week ending November 27.
Reactions McConville's son was critical of the adaption, saying that "[u]sing what happened to our mother for entertainment is sickening. To make money out of her murder and the pain that has been in our lives ever since is cruel and obscene. I doubt they even think of us as real people." On ,
Marian Price announced, through her solicitor, that she would be taking legal action against Disney+ over the series depicting her killing Jean McConville. On 2 July 2025 Price filed a claim against Disney in the Dublin High Court seeking damages and the removal of the scene in the ninth episode that showed her shooting McConville.
Accolades == Notes ==