There are many regional differences in Scottish folklore, some ancient, and some more modern which, according to James Porter "[stems] mainly from the great watershed of the eighteenth century when agricultural improvement began substantially to alter the character of the region". Additionally, Scottish history has been fraught with transformation due to the
Highland Clearances in the nineteenth century and battles over ownership such as the
Battle of Culloden. The Battle of Culloden, in 1746, as well as the
Battle of Harlaw in 1411 and the
Massacre of Glencoe in 1692, were historical traumas which have made their mark in Highland oral tradition and culture through songs and narratives. However, there has been an erosion in the passing of oral history, which noted oral historian
J. F. Campbell attributed to "the nature of school education and the proliferation of print culture" as well as "to the rise of technology, the railroad in particular". Campbell noted that the work attributed to the industrial revolution disrupted "communal work in which storytelling often took place," that "the chatter of communal labor was being drowned out by the hum of machinery". Although these beliefs are not as common, collectors such as J. F. Campbell,
Andrew Lang,
Hugh Miller and others, have dedicated themselves to recording these traditions and stories. Andrew Lang holds the belief that "superstitions contain aesthetic, psychological and cultural elements that are far more than irrational curiosities on the stepladder of civilization from primitive magic to enlightened science". Due to Scotland's regional differences, oral studies have "provided insights into the local and the specific, unique, particular cultures of place… framed in the local context". The Highlands and the Scottish Islands have been particularly isolated due to their location, offering a "wealth of Scottish folklore" for collectors of oral history. Through the study of folklore and folk belief, Scotland's culture "displays a world-view that integrated local history, Gaelic heroism, Christian piety, worldly wit and creativity into a shared vision to inspire, entertain, and educate the community". == Folklore related to place ==