When the film was first released, film critic
Bosley Crowther of
The New York Times was of mixed opinions: "If you want to be tough about it—okay, it's a pretty silly yarn and it is played in a manner no less fatuous by the sundry members of the cast. But Mr. Lang is still a director who knows how to turn the obvious, such as locked doors and silent chambers and roving spotlights, into strangely tingling stuff. And that's why, for all its psycho-nonsense, this film has some mildly creepy spots and some occasional faint resemblance to
Rebecca which it was obviously aimed to imitate."
Variety called it arty and almost surrealistic. The motivations of the characters were described as occasionally murky. New York's
PM was highly critical in 1948: "what they [Wanger, Lang, Bennett and Redgrave] have come up with is an utterly synthetic 'psychological' suspense incredibility wrapped in a gravity so pretentious it is to laugh, wherein all the actors stalk and stare like zombies while the sound track babbles fancy words."
Jonathan Rosenbaum of the
Chicago Reader called the film's murkiness a strength.
Rotten Tomatoes, a
review aggregator, reports that 54% of 13 surveyed critics gave the film a positive review; the average rating is 5.5/10. ==References==