Art critics
W. G. Archer and
Karl J. Khandalavala saw Sher-Gil as obsessed with Gauguin to the extent that it partly "haunted her". However, in contrast to Sher-Gil's portrayal of herself as a Tahitian, Gauguin's Tahitians are more elaborately dressed, are decorated with flowers, and typically appear as seductive women on a tropical landscape.
Saloni Mathur, professor of Modern and Contemporary South Asian Art, gives an alternative take. Bhushan and Christine Haupt call the "mystifying male shadow" a "
voyeur". She notes that the Indian art critic
Geeta Kapur connects Sher-Gil with the artist
Frida Kahlo; both representing "women in and through the experience of otherness", and therefore giving an alternative take of the traditional nude. In Sonal Khullar's view the painting "theatricalizes the relationship of French masters to the Orient" and "combines and confuses areas of the world: Oceania, the Orient, and the Occident". Pradeep A. Dhillon considers it of "eternal significance". ==Legacy==