Seven Psalms received positive reviews from music critics.
Jon Pareles at
The New York Times designated it a Critic's Pick, extolling it as "observant, elliptical, perpetually questioning and quietly encompassing". Chris Willman at
Variety called it "a testament to how inquisitive and engaged an artist can be this late in a career [...]
Seven Psalms is unlike any other Simon album in almost too many ways to list." Poppie Platt at
The Telegraph dubbed the effort "a half-shuttered window into the world of the man behind some of the world's most famous songs. If only Simon were to pry open said window slightly wider, one would feel more fulfilled."
Stephen Thomas Erlewine at
AllMusic found it continually revealing: "At first, the record can seem like a tone poem, a meditation of mortality and spirituality, yet each subsequent listen reveals a moment of grace or insight that helps pull the entirety of the project into relief." The album has been compared to
David Bowie's
Blackstar and
Leonard Cohen's
You Want It Darker, the artists’ final albums released in 2016. ==Track listing==