Critical response On
review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, 79% of critics have given the film a positive review based on 230 reviews, with an average rating of 7.5/10. The website's critics consensus reads, "Boasting stellar performances by Michael Fassbender and Carey Mulligan,
Shame is a powerful plunge into the mania of addiction affliction." On
Metacritic, it has a weighted average score of 72 out of 100, based on 41 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Roger Ebert of
Chicago Sun-Times gave the film four out of four stars and described it as "a powerful film" and "courageous and truthful", commenting that "this is a great act of filmmaking and acting. I don't believe I would be able to see it twice." Ebert later named it the second best film of 2011.
Todd McCarthy of
The Hollywood Reporter gave the film a positive review, stating, "Driven by a brilliant, ferocious performance by Michael Fassbender,
Shame is a real walk on the wild side, a scorching look at a case of
sexual addiction that's as all-encompassing as a craving for drugs." Dan Bullock of
The Hollywood News said, "
Shame is captivating and intensely intimate. McQueen has followed
Hunger with an unflinching and compelling film that explores the depths of addiction and the consequential destruction and demise of the mind and although it is sometimes difficult to watch, you won't be able to keep your eyes off it."
Justin Chang of
Variety gave the film a positive review, commenting, "A mesmerizing companion piece to his 2008 debut,
Hunger, this more approachable but equally uncompromising drama likewise fixes its gaze on the uses and abuses of the human body, as Michael Fassbender again strips himself down, in every way an actor can, for McQueen's rigorous but humane interrogation." Writing in
The New York Times,
A. O. Scott said, "McQueen wants to show how the intensity of Brandon's need shuts him off from real intimacy, but this seems to be a foregone conclusion, the result of an elegant experiment that was rigged from the start." Donald Clarke of
The Irish Times called it "the most wholesome film made about unwholesomeness since
The Exorcist" noting that "the underlying current of Puritanism is, however, more than a little oppressive". Writing for
MUBI,
Ignatiy Vishnevetsky said, "Every scene [is] ladled with big dollops of cinema's most respectable cop-out: ambiguity ...
Shame wears its emptiness like a badge of honor; McQueen is trying for banal blankness, and though he succeeds in that respect, you kind of wish that a filmmaker (and one with a background as an artist at that) would aspire to do more than just say nothing." In the blog for the British journal
The Art of Psychiatry,
psychiatrist Abby Seltzer praised Mulligan for her portrayal of an individual with
borderline personality disorder. While she had initially approached the film warily because of reviews that focused on Brandon's sex addiction, she found it "a moving and accurate portrayal of psychopathology ... [that should be] compulsory viewing for all practising clinicians."
Top-ten lists • 1st – David Fear,
Time Out New York • 1st – Gregory Ellwood,
HitFix • 2nd – Joshua Rothkopf,
Time Out New York • 2nd –
Roger Ebert,
Chicago Sun-Times • 2nd – Marc Savlov,
Austin Chronicle • 3rd –
Marshall Fine, Hollywood & Fine • 3rd – Peter Knegt,
Indiewire • 3rd –
James Berardinelli, Reelviews • 4th – Kimberley Jones,
Austin Chronicle • 5th – Kate Erbland,
Boxoffice Magazine • 5th – Kristopher Tapley,
HitFix • 5th –
Sasha Stone, Awards Daily • 6th – James Rocchi,
Boxoffice Magazine • 6th – Scott Feinberg,
The Hollywood Reporter • 6th – Elizabeth Weitzman,
New York Daily News • 6th – Christopher Bell,
Indiewire • 7th – Liam Lacey and Rick Groen,
The Globe and Mail • 7th – Aaron Hills,
Village Voice • 8th – Kevin Jagernauth,
Indiewire • 10th – Alison Willmore,
The A.V. Club • 10th – Don Kaye,
MSN Movies • 10th –
Todd McCarthy,
The Hollywood Reporter In 2016, it was ranked one of the 100 greatest motion pictures since 2000 in a critics' poll conducted by
BBC Culture.
Accolades ==References==