Throughout the run of
The Good Doctor, the character has polarized audiences. A 2019 study stated that audiences who watched
The Good Doctor gathered a greater knowledge of autism than they would have from a college lecture on the subject. Conversely, Autistic Doctors International founder Mary Doherty said that Murphy's portrayal was a "missed opportunity". In one scene, a convenience store robber tells Murphy to show his hands and hand him his wallet. In response, Murphy says that the robber "can't see [his] hands" if he reaches for his wallet, leading to the robber firing a shot and injuring a bystander; Autistic Women & Nonbinary Network senior advisor
Lydia Brown said that the scene was inaccurate. Brown also criticized the inaccuracy of Murphy as a
savant, a criticism shared by several researchers in
The Lancet. In
Mental Health Disorders on Television: Representation Versus Reality, Kimberley McMahon-Coleman and Roslyn Weaver compared Murphy with autistic savant Raymond Babbitt, played by
Dustin Hoffman in
Rain Man (1988), as did Murray Pomerance and R. Barton Palmer. In an essay published in
JAMA, Abigail Zuger posed the question on whether a doctor could succeed with autism, writing, "But should a persistent and profound inability to communicate with patients be considered a disability to be overcome in medicine or a nonnegotiable disqualification?" Zuger also noted the ambiguity of the show's title in reference to either Murphy or the various
persons of color within the show—such as Claire Brown (
Antonia Thomas) or Jared Kalu (
Chuku Modu); although Murphy saves lives, he does so at a greater cost than most other doctors. Murphy is the subject of a
bioethics study conducted in 2018, which found that the show could be used to teach bioethics to
health sciences students. Several researchers compared Murphy favorably to
Atypicals Sam Gardner and
Speechlesss JJ DiMio, who has
cerebral palsy, as an optimistic character. Critically, the character of Shaun Murphy has received some praise.
The New York Times television critic
James Poniewozik called Murphy an "anti-anti hero" in contrast to
Gregory House, the protagonist of
House; both shows were created by David Shore. In the season one episode "She", Murphy is shown failing to comprehend a
transgender patient.
Slate journalist Sara Luterman, who is autistic herself, noted
an overlap between autism and transgender individuals. Luterman later stated to
The Washington Post that although she reviewed the show's first season favorably, she no longer watches the show. ==References==