Doubts in the c't Initially, doubts were expressed about the credibility of Shift's corporate goals, which were formulated as fair. The computer magazine ''
c't'', for example, raised doubts about the fairness of the companies smartphone Shift5.1 in its 9/2016 issue. The article points out that the founder Carsten Waldeck did not provide any documents to support his statements. Also, statements of the Fair Production Manifesto on the manufacturer's website are remarkably vague. Furthermore, the manifesto was written by Waldeck and "signed by 'Aaron, the founder and CEO of Vstar and Weihuaxin', a company based in Shenzen, China". The company, which according to c't von Waldeck is referred to as the "main partner", in turn has the shiftphones manufactured by another company. According to c't, the manifesto is thus merely "a declaration of intent by the shift-maker, not an investigation report by an at least halfway independent third party. The conclusion of the article is correspondingly harsh on Shift5.1: it should not be considered a fairphone alternative, but merely a typical cheap smartphone.
Mixed representation at Utopia The german ecology online portal
Utopia.de also described the efforts towards more sustainable production as "intransparent". Nevertheless, Shift5 was then included in a top list of ecological smartphones.
Further representations In contrast, the magazine
Digitale Welt writes that the company attaches just as much importance to environmentally friendly measures as it does to fair working conditions and reparability. The latter is achieved through the concept of modular construction of the devices, whose individual parts can be ordered by the user and repaired with commercially available tools and tutorials.
Reports after 2017 More recent reports paint a clearer picture. Articles in other magazines have also been able to capture Carsten Waldeck's statements and prove their credibility accordingly. In June 2018, for example,
golem.de of
Computec Media reported in detail about the company and its efforts in the areas of sustainability and fairness.
ProSieben magazine
Galileo also tested - also in June 2018 - the newly published Shift6m and used video recordings to illuminate the production conditions of the in-house Shift factory on site in China. In September 2018,
N-tv described the initial efforts towards fairness and sustainability as well as the history of the Shift phone's development. The computer magazine c't found more positive words about the German smartphone manufacturer in issue 15/2018, although the reporting in the context of other European providers is very brief. The ecology portal Utopia.de also no longer mentions intransparency in an article from August 2018. On December 7, 2018,
Deutsche Welle headlines: "Smartphone and sustainability - is that possible? With the shiftphone it is!". == References ==