The signing of
Shillong Accord appears to have provided the final solution for the preceding 20 years of conflict; a large-scale of arms were surrendered, and the villagers enthusiastically participated in persuading the Naga underground rebels to join the mainstream. The agreement can also be interpreted as a victory for Indian government as Naga rebels agreed to accept the Indian constitution of their own volition, agreed to deposit the arms, and formulate other issues for discussions as part of final settlement.
Criticism The detractors and critics of the Accord maintained that
Clause 3 (which set out "reasonable time for the underground representatives to formulate other issues for discussion for the final settlement") remained unimplemented - as most of the
Naga people and the
Naga National Council leaders abroad didn't agree to endorse the agreement. They also criticized the fact that the agreement was signed by "representatives of the Naga underground," rather than the organizations like NNC or the
Federal Government of Nagaland. Many
Nagas, who were not reconciled being part of Indian union of states, condemned the agreement that ultimately created
factionalism among the rebels. When the negotiations were going on before signing the agreement, it is said that
Isak Chishi Swu, then-NNC Vice-president, and
Thuingaleng Muivah, then-NNC General secretary, with 150 rebels were on their way back from
China and
Burma-Naga territory where they established their base. Some critics also point out that
Phizo, then-NNC president and who was in
exile from 1956 in
London, neither endorsed nor renounced the agreement; though, his younger brother Kevi Yalley represented underground organizations and signed
Shillong Accord. It is also believed that both Isak and Muivah tried their best to convince some of their colleagues, especially Phizo to condemn the agreement, including sending a seven-member delegation urging Phizo to condemn the
Shillong Accord without delay; however, it looks Phizo remained silent and their voice went unheard. ==See also==