Shine was met with generally positive reviews. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from professional publications, the album received an
average score of 73, based on 18 reviews. Jon Caramanica from
The New York Times called
Shine a "charming if sometimes blithe second album [with] a more modern antecedent: the decade-old
Miseducation of Lauryn Hill.
Rolling Stones Jody Rosen fund that with
Shine "Estelle offers a gritty alternative to R&B; divadom's strutting fembots." But [the] Yanks don't dilute
Shines regional feel — this West London homegirl's perspective is etched in her husky singing, fleet—tongued rapping and wised—up lyrics. The music encompasses rugged modern R&B, dancehall,
Sarah Vaughan-style jazz vocalese and, on "No Substitute Love," a reggae-soul-hip—hop torch song." Rodney Dugue, writing for
The Village Voice felt that "Estelle turns
Shine into a durable debut, pleasant and shrewd." ==Commercial performance==