On release,
GamePro gave
Shining Force CD a mixed review. They praised the quality of the strategic gameplay and graphics perspectives but were critical of the fact that the game doesn't significantly differ from its predecessors
Shining Force and
Shining Force II in either of those elements. A reviewer for
Next Generation, while concurring that the game differs little from its predecessors in the mechanics, felt that the new content was enough to keep the game fresh even to fans of the series. Citing the exciting battles, detailed fight animations, and sense of exploration, he deemed
Shining Force CD a must-have for Sega CD owners and gave it four out of five stars.
Retro Gamer included this "almost overwhelming" and "epic" title among their top ten Mega CD games. Though
Next Generation listed all the
Genesis and Sega CD entries of the
Shining series collectively as number 77 on their list of the "Top 100 Games of All Time", they made special note of
Shining Force CD as "one of the largest RPGs ever made". ==References==